Evidence for a Tribunal — Scope | Disability forum
Find out how to let us know if you're concerned about another member's safety.

Evidence for a Tribunal

saraleighuk Member Posts: 4 Listener
edited November 2017 in PIP, DLA, and AA

Following my PiP assessment I was downgraded to a standard award and don’t agree with the reasoning for this. For example I cannot stand up from sitting on a chair or toilet but they won’t include this in the toiletting score as first the assessor said that because I have good dexterity in my hands I can get up from the toilet, and when appealed I was told that as I can get out my car I can get off the toilet or a seat (please tell my muscles that, also my car is a high up car and I did state I do need help out the car at the end of the day as I’m tired) 

It didn’t help the situation that I ensured my assessment was at a location that had 2 Disabled bays outside so I could walk in and show how it affects me, but on the morning they had a skip delivered and parked it over both bays and meant I had to park some distance away so had to use my mobility scooter and although I offered to get out to show I can’t stand up unassisted I was told it was fine. Grr and did mention about the skips too to both them and PiP as if I was alone I wouldn’t have been able to attend.

Anyway, I heard it mentioned somewhere that people have used their previous DWP reports for PiP evidence. I was much more mobile and capable then and got the higher award. I will be getting a report from my hospitals for the appeals, but just wanted to check the previous reports are available from the PiP information line (I don’t want to call for them to tell me they aren’t as the person doesn’t know what they’re doing)

Also, I have Muscular Dystrophy and it won’t get any better (unless there’s a miracle cure) but I’ve been told I’ll be reassessed again in 2022. Am I able to ask them to consider a decision for life if they find I am at the highest award? I will only stay the same or get worse. 

Thank you



  • Markmywords
    Markmywords Member Posts: 419 Pioneering
    Hello @saraleighuk ,

    The Tribunal will want to focus on the evidence you gave for the recent assessment. They will decide if the DWP acted properly in reaching their decision on it.

    However, since DWP decisions are based on contradicting the evidence you should concentrate there.

    Go through the PIP descriptors and explain how your statements and evidence should have given an "x" points award. You can introduce new medical evidence that supports the truth of your statements and medical conditions.

    Yes, you can ask for the term to be reviewed in the hope of the "it is not appropriate to set a term." award (or whatever the wording is.)
    However, the DWP will still assess you in 10 years "for your own good" and "to make sure you are receiving the correct support."
    It has been said that the DWP will claim "new evidence" means the court award can be superseded. So you might have another fight then.
  • Pippa_Alumni
    Pippa_Alumni Scope alumni Posts: 5,793 Disability Gamechanger
    Hi @saraleighuk, and welcome to the community!

    So sorry to hear about your recent experiences, and particularly about the skips blocking the disabled bays: that's appalling! Markmywords has given some good advice above, but let us know if you need any further clarification or if there's anything else we can assist you with. You might also be interested in Scope's advice on appealing a DWP decision.
  • saraleighuk
    saraleighuk Member Posts: 4 Listener
    Thank you both, that’s great to hear. 

    I’m just worried I’ll have to go through this all again in a few years if it is agreed, but hopefully I’ll be able to base anything on this decision. (I plan too far in advance!)

    I’ve got my reasoning behind why I believe I should be entitled to each score so I’ll concentrate on getting the medical evidence now. Thank you :)
  • saraleighuk
    saraleighuk Member Posts: 4 Listener
    Thank you. Unfortunately I can’t get up even with handrails and even explained to the assessor that an occupational therapist put in a report for a toilet riser lift which I’m currently trying to fund as the council won’t pay the £3500, and currently have to rely on being physically lifted up. The reason I said getting up from a chair was just so they can see how I have to be lifted etc in the assessment as an example as first she said as I have good dexterity I could get up myself, but I don’t have the muscle strength in my back, legs or arms to get up 

    they don’t seem to be able to take my word for it - I wish I could just film my whole day to show everything lol 
  • saraleighuk
    saraleighuk Member Posts: 4 Listener
    Thank you. It’s so frustrating as I used all the above and more as evidence to appeal to DWP and it’s like they didn’t even read it but at least at a face to face tribunal it will definately be reviewed and I can answer their questions to further explain.

    Thank you 


Complete our feedback form and tell us how we can make the community better.

Do you need advice on your energy costs?

Scope’s Disability Energy Support service is open to any disabled household in England or Wales in which one or more disabled people live. You can get free advice from an expert adviser on managing energy debt, switching tariffs, contacting your supplier and more. Find out more information by visiting our
Disability Energy Support webpage.