Saving the planet

Dragonslayer
Online Community Member Posts: 2,164 Pioneering
With all the protests / arguments going on about global warming and saving the planet.
Protesters are demanding we do things like giving up are cars, stop flying, stop using the heating systems we have, stop eating meat. Etc.
The list goes on and on. It's sometimes makes me think we are taking all the technology we have invented over the past few decades and throwing it all in the bin, stopping al progress and going back to the dark ages.
There are new systems coming on stream for nearly everything, and all seems to be moving towards renewable energy.
But how long before they protest about us using too much of that?
Would you, could you, give up your car? Would you, could you ride a bike instead?
A great deal of people like use cars just to get around and we can't (Because of our disability's) ride a bike. Yes, we are moving to electric cars. But how long before they start to protest over us using too much electricity.?
Can people in the future stop using mobile phones for instance? Along with all the other tech things we have now and use.
I can't see the youth of today stopping using many of the things, they have now, or the things that will probably come along in future.
Then there is the question, will there be a future?
Then the question, What about all the other countries and what they are doing, or not doing. Will what we do make that a difference if they do nothing?
Protesters are demanding we do things like giving up are cars, stop flying, stop using the heating systems we have, stop eating meat. Etc.
The list goes on and on. It's sometimes makes me think we are taking all the technology we have invented over the past few decades and throwing it all in the bin, stopping al progress and going back to the dark ages.
There are new systems coming on stream for nearly everything, and all seems to be moving towards renewable energy.
But how long before they protest about us using too much of that?
Would you, could you, give up your car? Would you, could you ride a bike instead?
A great deal of people like use cars just to get around and we can't (Because of our disability's) ride a bike. Yes, we are moving to electric cars. But how long before they start to protest over us using too much electricity.?
Can people in the future stop using mobile phones for instance? Along with all the other tech things we have now and use.
I can't see the youth of today stopping using many of the things, they have now, or the things that will probably come along in future.
Then there is the question, will there be a future?
Then the question, What about all the other countries and what they are doing, or not doing. Will what we do make that a difference if they do nothing?
1
Comments
-
Hi @Dragonslayer, I have never had a car in all my life and I feel that I've missed out on a lot of things that just can't be done with public transport. If public transport was to be vastly improved and fares kept down, then people might want to give up their cars. But it's unreasonable, especially in rural areas, to demand that people give up their cars when there's no viable alternative. Energy saving is great as long as it's easily accessible to all. The protesters would achieve more if they presented the government and public with specific information and suggestions on how things can be improved.2
-
I think with many of them it's just virtue signalling and oneupmanship rather than an actual desire to save the planet. I actually think that they enjoy being in the minority so that they can come across as superior to and more virtuous than the rest of us. I think if we all adopted their way of life then they may well adopt some other way of life to once again come across as superior. If we gave up everything they wanted us to give up then like you suggest they would just find something else we shouldn't be doing and protest about that instead.
I'm not suggesting that there is no climate change but I won't pretend to know what the answer is, however, I'm inclined to listen to qualified and educated individuals, not shouty people with banners.
I think I could quite easily give up using my car as driving is mostly just a hobby for me (we go to shops but only for a drive, we could quite easily use the shops in our home town) but I choose not to as it's good for my mental health. I'm planning on getting an electric car when my Motability car needs renewing, if I am still eligible for one. I could also easily give up my mobile phone. I don't think I could give up my laptop, though!
1 -
I think the thing that really gets my back up is being preached to by celebrities...telling us all what to do before hopping on another private jet to a climate change conference...
A lot of us can't afford to be anything other then eco friendly..1 -
It's way too late, Mother Nature has had enough and now she's fighting back. People have abused her and only now are they realising what damage has been done.0
-
We'll have to start fitting air conditioning systems and painting houses white as standard in the UK in a few years time...
I've barely been able to do anything over the last 4 months due to the heat exacerbating my health issues...I dread the summer every year and it's only going to get worse in future. Sadly a human cull isn't part of the climate fix, I'd be first in line if it was!
I don't believe electric cars are the way forward either, we're in a transitional period of trial & error right now... I genuinely believe they'll end up in a pile next to the Betamax's and Minidiscs. They're alright for a small town runaround, but will never be viable for people driving big mileages for work. Not to mention the UK's electricity infrastructure isn't there to support them in vast numbers either.
I agree with @Oxonlady regarding extinction rebellion...if they were putting the effort into viable solutions with costs and timescales considered then they'd have a good argument. Simply whining that you want something done, but don't know what or how, isn't helping anyone.1 -
I probably won't be around to see the devastation in 30 years but my grandchildren will (all being well) I feel sorry for future generations0
-
As far as generating electricity is concerned this may help in the future
https://www.sciencenews.org/article/laser-nuclear-fusion-experiment-energy
0 -
Hi @66Mustang. If driving is your hobby, then it is a good hobby, keep it up.
I have been retired now for some time and since my wife retired over a year ago, I now do the same as you. But it is nice to know it is there to use whenever needed. Like I drove to Cornwall a few weeks ago for a holiday. But I do engage in the 'hobby' often. ?
I have a mobile phone and use it as such. (A phone) for convivence. Many seem to be a slave to their phones when it was invented to be our slave. I can't imagine taking mine to bed with me for instance, like many do. Mine sits in the room switched off until I need it. I have a desktop computer as well as a laptop and couldn't give up either.
Hi @Oxonlady. I understand what you say about public transport. Somone once said to me. (When public transport can pick me up from home and drop me to the door of where I want to go, then bring me back when needed. I might consider using it.) We will never ever get to that I'm sure. But I do see the point. ? I agree protesters, just protest. Maybe they have nothing better to do and just want to vent.
Hi @Username_removed. I understand and welcome your views and these are just my thoughts on your comments. I can't comment on Facebook, I don't use it. My wife being American uses it to keep in touch with her family back there, cheaper and easier than phone, or e-mail. But she does use those also.
Google gives us information when we need it. Although I use Microsoft edge. But Before we had those, we had no way other way to find the information we may need on many topics.
Amazon is the easiest way to buy many things and help improve smaller businesses to expand and grow.
Both Amazon and Google started with an idea in a garage. Facebook in a student's boarding room. Like many others they started from nothing ang by using technology progressed to where they are now. So, for me technology and progress go hand in hand.
0 -
Username_removed said:I can’t agree re: Extinction Rebellion. The reason this is even on our governments agenda or being discussed here is in large part because of the work they’ve done. The old “if they had viable solutions” argument wholly misunderstands what they’re about. The aim was to cause enough disruption to force the discussion. Does anyone really think climate change in the UK would be any more than an occasional flood, fire, rainfall discussion if ER hadn’t clogged up the legal system.
I don't believe the issue is one of ignorance towards the subject. But more that much of the general public couldn't care less until it directly affects them. And those that do care are unable to make changes due to finances, accessibility, availability or simply because the UK is now designed around the car. 50 years ago you could get everything you need on your street...no longer since supermarkets and huge out of town stores...and the fact we're having to build further and further away from every town centre now. Can't get a full weeks shopping on a bus or bicycle even for those able to use them. The government doesn't have the finances to make the necessary changes (especially after Covid) and they can't force the huge societal change that's needed on the public either. The change needs to be welcomed by the public. Frustrating people by blocking roads isn't going to do that...if anything, it's just going to wind them up and make them retaliate by rebelling against the solution, as can be seen across the internet over the last few days. Human behaviour needs to be taken into account here, same as it was for the Covid restrictions.
Of course, I don't have a solution either (apart from the above mention human cull) so maybe I'm just as bad here!0 -
@woodbine I agree.
I also think that many young people in Extinction Rebellion will I'm sure at some time, drive, fly and use other forms of transport, especially when they get settled into jobs ECT. (If they ever do)
Like many of us will they want to take the time to walk, then stand and wait in a bus queue in a gale force wind with the rain, cold and snow lashing down, or ride a bike? Or maybe they will protest about having to go out in such conditions just for work?
I walked 2miles a day to and from work in any weather for years, before I could drive at 23. Just like many others did at that time, because we were expected to get to work on time whatever. I believe that today such values have been lost.
0 -
I'm very uneducated and not particularly intelligent so bear that in mind.(I don't mean please be nice to poor little me)..but I kind of think there's no shoving genies back in bottles, rather find better ways to deal with the stuff the genie spewed out...
More effort and money in making plastic bio degradable ...stop making white goods that are made to be obsolete..
Nobody is going to want to stop driving, flying etc but public transport is rubbish and expensive in this country .
And where the hell were the thinking caps when it came to micro beads in products etc...
I just don't think telling people to stop doing stuff that's been taken for granted for so long is going to work so deal with the problems that, that causes.
Maybe it'll all be left for Hughie dewy and lewie.0 -
Did anyone see that the leader of Extinction Rebellion drives a Range Rover?
Not sure how true it is - there are 2 sides to every story of course and the news may well be being sensational - but if it is true then I find the hypocrisy a bit disgusting to be honest.1 -
Hi there @66Mustang
I saw that also.
I also saw that the protesters left behind more than 120tonns of rubbish. I guess some of that was the plastic they so desperately want us to stop using. Not one of them attempted to help clear it up either. Hypocrisy?
1 -
Username_removed said:Goodness me. Is it that hard to check facts?Username_removed said:She drives a diesel.Username_removed said:It always seems to me that targeting the alleged hypocrisy of people who have actually got off their arses to do something rather than the hypocrisy of your local MP who likely drives something bigger and do nothing to challenge climate change is very much a case of getting your priorities wrong.0
-
Mike [removed by moderator] well expressed. I agreed with every word. People could do worse than looking on-line at the XR policies, and their objectives. Also, importantly, their appeal for help from disabled people and people who don't wish to, or could not, use transport of any kind to reach a physical protest site.
They have an online campaign. Everyone can join in. Their first target is Barclays, who give more funding to fossil fuel than the whole of Europe does. They also want to protest about governments, including UK, who actually subsidise use of fossil fuel.
The reason they are mainly protesting in the City of London, because pension funds and other major sources of money are pouring it into planet destroying businesses.
The Green Party has had some influence in Europe, due to proportional representation. Sadly, they have grabbed onto simplistic one-size ideas. They wanted wood fired boilers, so American forests were felled to make fuel pellets, to be shipped to UK to be burned. Wood burning is a disaster.
Diesel cars was one of their demands. They got diesel cars, then noticed they were a disaster.
They wanted home insulation, which in itself is fine, but it transformed into a one-size obsession with cavity-wall-and loft, which ruined many houses and made them unsaleable. (Spray foam inside roof tiles is having to be removed, because trapped damp rots timbers, and cavity wall filling caused disaster in many cases)
The latest one-size is battery cars, and the idea that tree planting will 'offset' the harm everything else does.
Already the idea of battery cars is being seen as not a one-size triumph after all, and as for tree planting, it has immediately been perverted into get-rich quick schemes.
Nothing has been done to avoid destruction of peat, which is a terrible thing to do. Planning consent is being given for ripping them up to create housing estates. It is still not illegal to dig them up for compost, or even for burning as fuel. Other peat bogs are being ripped up to plant subsidised tree plantations of single species trees, with the intention of rapidly felling them.
Even now UK is out of EU, and could easily declare the entire UK coastal waters are marine parks. (It is not impossible Eirre would wish to join in that scheme, EU or not) The advantage is that it allows fishing to be only using methods a marine conservationist would approve, and only by boats licenced by marine conservationists. Instead, boats from anywhere in the world but notably France are using dredging which destroys the sea bed and all potential habitat for nurseries for hatchling fish. In less than 30 years, there will be a greater weight plastic in the seas than of fish.
Probably the worst thing of all is the elephant in the room of the human population explosion. Every country in the world needs to have immediate measures to reverse this.
It's code red for humanity. As XR say, Act Now Because It's Too Late.
P.S. The best thing to do about Christmas and every other form of avoidable mindless consumerism is to use our brains for the reason we evolved to do, and think for ourselves.
(Children are ahead of elders, and they have a movement to refuse plastic toys. But buying anything new or single use or avoidable is always something to be carefully considered. 'Flight-Shame' is a major movement in Scandinavia. 'New-Clothes-Shame' is beginning to influence influencers, who prefer to be seen in their own clothes repeatedly, or have them altered, or else to hire clothes, or use swap systems, anything to avoid throw-away single wear clothes. Denim is never acceptable, due to the water use growing and processing cotton and the dye pollution.)
P.P.S. Unusually, I left the adverts on T,V. with the sound on, while doing something else. It was astonishing that one after another was advertising products with scent. (Fake lemon scent is a particular problem) Chemical scent is damaging to health, and even carcinogenic. I believe some countries ban those air scenters, which are carcinogenic. No fake scent is safe, and it makes many people really ill. Asthmatics and others can have serious breathing problems if exposed to this poison. It is every bit as bad as imposing second-hand smoke on people. Why isn't it banned?
(Why isn't palm oil banned?)
1 -
Yes climate change is real but until China and India and a few others do stuff it doesn’t matter what we do what we are are a small percentage of the real issue.
my issue is how it’s all on the consumer we have to pay more meanwhile these big corporations are not.
yes the gov in all countries need to do more but you know while we penalise folks other countries are pumping some right fumes etc out.
some one mentioned about summer it’s not been hot I think we had one week that was it’s been rainy apparantly all to do with climate change.
0 -
Surely the point about getting all countries to reach agreement still stands?
We may be doing more harm based on population, but it's still a relatively small population and in the scheme of things just us doing our bit wouldn't be anywhere near enough to make a difference.
I don't think that means we shouldn't bother but I do think we'd be better served dealing with the pollution we 've created and focusing on how to provide clean energy for powering our vehicles and heating our homes etc. Instead of just telling people to stop driving and put a jumper on.
And how do you get countries like brasil to stop clearing the rain forests in order to make land to farm and make a living from?
And population growth?0 -
@Username_removed said.
Based on our population size Britain is the biggest single contributor to greenhouse gasses on the planet. China comes in at 19th.
Wherever I look China is at the top of the list of greenhouse gas emissions. Britain comes in at 17 -19.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 15.4K Start here and say hello!
- 7.3K Coffee lounge
- 88 Games den
- 1.7K People power
- 119 Announcements and information
- 24.1K Talk about life
- 5.8K Everyday life
- 423 Current affairs
- 2.4K Families and carers
- 872 Education and skills
- 1.9K Work
- 533 Money and bills
- 3.6K Housing and independent living
- 1.1K Transport and travel
- 627 Relationships
- 1.5K Mental health and wellbeing
- 2.5K Talk about your impairment
- 866 Rare, invisible, and undiagnosed conditions
- 923 Neurological impairments and pain
- 2.1K Cerebral Palsy Network
- 1.2K Autism and neurodiversity
- 39.9K Talk about your benefits
- 6K Employment and Support Allowance (ESA)
- 19.7K PIP, DLA, ADP and AA
- 8.4K Universal Credit (UC)
- 5.7K Benefits and income