*Phone Call From DWP Regarding PIP & Tribunal* — Scope | Disability forum
Find out how to let us know if you're concerned about another member's safety.

*Phone Call From DWP Regarding PIP & Tribunal*

MW9
MW9 Member Posts: 19 Courageous
edited July 2018 in PIP, DLA, and AA
Hi,

I’m wondering if anyone can shed some light on this? 

My PIP award was up for reviewing at the end of last year and after sending all the information and having an assessment I was subsequently kept on the same rates as previously (standard for both). I detailed on the forms and in person as much as I could how everything that affects me has gotten worse and impacted me. I sent a very detailed Mandatory Reconsideration letter decribing absolutely everything and got my points on the care component bumped from 8 to 11 with the mobility points staying the same at 10. I of course then took the next step and sent all the relevant documentation to initiate a tribunal. 

As of earlier today I received a phone call from a woman from the DWP saying that she’s reviewed all the information available and would be willing to give me the enhanced mobility which means I then wouldn’t need to go to a tribunal. Now, as much as I don’t want to attend a tribunal I firmly believe based on all my health conditions, the evidence that’s been sent, medication, doctors reports etc that I should be entitled to enhanced on both. Has anyone else heard of a similar phone call to void a tribunal? Is it maybe because they know what I’m more than likely to win the tribunal based on my health and all the evidence and they’re just trying to meet me half way by offering me enhanced on one of the components? I said I’d need to think about it and to phone her back.

Any feedback or advice would be greatly appreciated.

Many thanks. 
«1

Comments

  • poppy123456
    poppy123456 Member Posts: 28,427 Disability Gamechanger
    Hi,
    Yes this can and does happen. If the DWP think that a decision will go in your favour for any part then there's a chance they could offer to up your award before the hearing takes place, which they have.

    You don't have to accept this offer if you don't want to. You have every right to continue with the Tribunal. There's no risk, if a Tribunal plan on lowering an existing award they must contact you before the Tribunal hearing. As you've got this far, for the sake of 1 single point if it was me then i'd certainly continue.

    Good luck!
  • wilko
    wilko Member Posts: 2,449 Disability Gamechanger
    Hello MW9, welcome it's a difficult one this you think you should be awarded the enhanced rate for care and mobility and they are offering you enhanced mobility if you accept  and you don't proceed to tribunal. The thing is has your care needs, do they meet the criteria to get the enhanced rate or is it mainly your mobility that qualify more towards the enhanced rate? If your care needs are boarder line for enhanced rate whereas you're mobility is as such that you easily meet the criteria for the enhanced rate then maybe the DWP have reviewed your evidence that was submitted at the start of the claim which is all they can look a even if your health has worsened. If you do not accept the offer and proceed to tribunal only the medical notes information that was available, submitted at the start of your claim and used at your acessment will be allowed and a judgement, award made on the evidence provided at the claim start regardless of any worsening health or mobility issues. Take advice form CAB or others who I am sure will give a comment or opinion. Good luck and keep us updated and keep posting.
  • atlas46
    atlas46 Member Posts: 826 Pioneering
    Hi

    A very warm welcome.

    Poppy is correct, the DWP is now trying to stop cases that they know they will lose.

    Have you got someone to assist you at the tribunal?

    I would let the DWP know than you are going to the tribunal, see if they have another change of mind, in your favour.

    Keep us informed and good luck.
  • MW9
    MW9 Member Posts: 19 Courageous
    Thanks for the replies so far from everyone, instead of replying individually I’d thought it best to cover everyone’s points.

    I agree with them offering me enhanced for the mobility of course as I meet all the relevant points and descriptors, it’s the fact I feel they’ve still greatly overlooked the care component of my claim. It shouldn’t really even be touch and go as I rely on my partner for everything regarding help getting clothed, toilet needs, bathing, medication, amongst many other things. 

    The original mandatory reconsideration letter I sent was 23 pages worth, a very lengthy and detailed account of absolutely everything I could think of, I left no stone unturned which resulted in the care component going from 8 points to 11 points, still many points short of what I realistically should be awarded.

    When I phone the woman back on Monday and say I appreciate them offering me enhanced on mobility and mention that I’ll need to politely decline it due to not being awarded enhanced for care, does anyone know the likelihood of them then settling for enhanced for both?

    Like everyone else who’s went though it, I really don’t want to attend a tribunal due to the added stress and anxiety it brings, but I don’t want to settle for the convenient revised offer when I know it’s still not accurate to my circumstances.


  • mikehughescq
    mikehughescq Posts: 8,845 Connected
    This is the new routine. DWP have always been able to review at any time but they’d usually let stuff go to appeal. In the last few weeks there has been a complete turnaround and you’ll get this “offer” call on most cases at present. Several things to say.

    1 - nothing to stop you carrying on.
    2 - nothing to stop you accepting the offer so you get extra money now and then reappeal the remaining component. You wouldn’t have to do another MR.
    3 - very important to understand what length of award is on offer. Seen a few cases where they offer enhanced rate but for a shorter period. If you think it should be ongoing then argue your case. They’ll often come back with a 2nd or 3rd offer.
  • debbiedo49
    debbiedo49 Member Posts: 2,904 Disability Gamechanger
    Good luck whatever you do 
  • MW9
    MW9 Member Posts: 19 Courageous
    This is the new routine. DWP have always been able to review at any time but they’d usually let stuff go to appeal. In the last few weeks there has been a complete turnaround and you’ll get this “offer” call on most cases at present. Several things to say.

    1 - nothing to stop you carrying on.
    2 - nothing to stop you accepting the offer so you get extra money now and then reappeal the remaining component. You wouldn’t have to do another MR.
    3 - very important to understand what length of award is on offer. Seen a few cases where they offer enhanced rate but for a shorter period. If you think it should be ongoing then argue your case. They’ll often come back with a 2nd or 3rd offer.
    Hi Mike,

    Thanks for the information. I didn’t realise I could accept their revised offer then reappeal, just one question though, would that not backdate the whole process which is already quite lengthy? 

    I’ve had my PIP extended for another 4 years, however my health and mobility conditions are ongoing and will continue to be as such, so that’s another point I’ll need to relay to them, which I have done previously but it seems to have fallen on deaf ears unfortunately.

    I get the impression that they know I should have been awarded enhanced for both components in the first place and they’re simply trying to meet me half way by now offering me enhanced on just the mobility, with them hoping I reluctantly accept this offer and not going through with a tribunal.

    I’m unsure of the chances of the woman awarding me enhanced for both components when I phone her back on Monday, but I can only be polite and stand firm on my views and if to no avail, continue with taking it to a tribunal. 
  • mikehughescq
    mikehughescq Posts: 8,845 Connected
    Not sure what you mean by “backdate the whole process”. Do you mean delay?

    There’s been some debate about this but the consensus in the Davy e world is that yes you can go back to appeal. See https://www.rightsnet.org.uk/forums/viewthread/12980/
  • MW9
    MW9 Member Posts: 19 Courageous
    Not sure what you mean by “backdate the whole process”. Do you mean delay?

    There’s been some debate about this but the consensus in the Davy e world is that yes you can go back to appeal. See https://www.rightsnet.org.uk/forums/viewthread/12980/
    Sorry, yes I meant delay. As the wheels are set in motion so to speak, would it further delay the process if I were to take this route? 

    I had read that linked post earlier, some interesting points made in it. I’d just be worried to accept the revised offer they’ve given then possibly lose the right to still appeal to a tribunal. I’m new to all this and still trying to gain as much knowledge and learn about the ins and outs to give me the best opportunity to be awarded the correct points for both components. 
  • mikehughescq
    mikehughescq Posts: 8,845 Connected
    Well yes it would delay but then balancing that is getting the right outcome. Put it this way. If DWP thought they could win the appeal they wouldn’t be on the phone to you.
  • Yadnad
    Yadnad Posts: 2,856 Connected
    atlas46 said:
    Hi

    A very warm welcome.

    Poppy is correct, the DWP is now trying to stop cases that they know they will lose.

    Have you got someone to assist you at the tribunal?

    I would let the DWP know than you are going to the tribunal, see if they have another change of mind, in your favour.

    Keep us informed and good luck.
    You may well find that if you refuse the 'offer' they will withdraw it and allow the appeal to continue. No mention will be made at the Tribunal that the offer was made.
    Personally I don't understand why they do this. If the DWP think that they will lose why don't they just go ahead and change the award?

  • clarabelle
    clarabelle Member Posts: 71 Courageous
    I'm at review stage for pip ( my award being fixed november 15 -April 19).  The original award of standard daily living and 0 points for mobility being overturned at tribunal and an award of enhanced DL & 4 points for mobility. The mobility element is now awaiting upper tribunal. 
    I just attended a capita medical for my review and was told I would receive a copy of the report and a decision within 4 weeks.
    Am I likely to receive a phone call from the dwp asking me to haggle or is this only happening after requests for MR? 
  • mikehughescq
    mikehughescq Posts: 8,845 Connected
    Beginning to see it happen at all stages, which is as it should be.
  • MW9
    MW9 Member Posts: 19 Courageous
    Well yes it would delay but then balancing that is getting the right outcome. Put it this way. If DWP thought they could win the appeal they wouldn’t be on the phone to you.
    I understand, that was my inclination originally, as I wasn’t expecting a phone call at all from DWP, but suppose they’re trying to get me to agree to what they’ve offered to save them the time and effort of it going to a tribunal.
  • MW9
    MW9 Member Posts: 19 Courageous
    edited July 2018
    Yadnad said:
    atlas46 said:
    Hi

    A very warm welcome.

    Poppy is correct, the DWP is now trying to stop cases that they know they will lose.

    Have you got someone to assist you at the tribunal?

    I would let the DWP know than you are going to the tribunal, see if they have another change of mind, in your favour.

    Keep us informed and good luck.
    You may well find that if you refuse the 'offer' they will withdraw it and allow the appeal to continue. No mention will be made at the Tribunal that the offer was made.
    Personally I don't understand why they do this. If the DWP think that they will lose why don't they just go ahead and change the award?

    Hi Yadnad,

    I know, it’s such a drawn out, frustrating process. It’s the fact that after my mandatory reconsideration letter they awarded me an additional 3 points to the care component putting it to 11 points from 8, now with this phone call they’re offering to increase my mobility from 10 points to over 12 points (or over) for the enchanted rate.

    That alone highlights the extreme discrepancies in the process when they can alter the award twice from the original decision they gave.

    Although I’m happy they’re now recognising my mobility issues and are willing to award the correct points for that component, the 11 points on the care component still doesn’t reflect the level of care my partner has to provide and qmy daily situations and how I have to cope with them, so for the sake of 1 point I’m definitely but reluctantly going through with the tribunal, unless they unexpectedly offer me enhanced for both when I phone back on Monday.

    To touch upon your point about no mention of the offer being made at the tribunal, I’m going to record the phone call and provide that as further evidence if needed.
  • mikehughescq
    mikehughescq Posts: 8,845 Connected
    MW9 said:
    Well yes it would delay but then balancing that is getting the right outcome. Put it this way. If DWP thought they could win the appeal they wouldn’t be on the phone to you.
    I understand, that was my inclination originally, as I wasn’t expecting a phone call at all from DWP, but suppose they’re trying to get me to agree to what they’ve offered to save them the time and effort of it going to a tribunal.
    It’s no effort at all for a P.O to attend. They love it. Time out of the office with the crossword and the ability to go straight home afterwards if the last case was adjourned. It’s about money.

    Incidentally you cannot record a call legally without consent.
  • MW9
    MW9 Member Posts: 19 Courageous
    MW9 said:
    Well yes it would delay but then balancing that is getting the right outcome. Put it this way. If DWP thought they could win the appeal they wouldn’t be on the phone to you.
    I understand, that was my inclination originally, as I wasn’t expecting a phone call at all from DWP, but suppose they’re trying to get me to agree to what they’ve offered to save them the time and effort of it going to a tribunal.
    It’s no effort at all for a P.O to attend. They love it. Time out of the office with the crossword and the ability to go straight home afterwards if the last case was adjourned. It’s about money.

    Incidentally you cannot record a call legally without consent.
    You’re right, they’ll no doubt treat it as an extended lunch break.

    From what I’ve read, you can legally record a call without consent as long as it’s for personal use, but if you’re relaying the call onto a third party then you need to gain consent. I wonder the possibility of them either retracting their offer or not mentioning it if I were to state at the beginning of the call that it’s being recorded.
  • mikehughescq
    mikehughescq Posts: 8,845 Connected
    It’s not a criminal offence but it is potentially a civil one and runs the risk of a claim for damages. So, yes, you could in theory record the call but why if you can’t share it and why if by sharing it you run the risk of a civil claim. 

    I would suggest that trying to use the recording of a call as a threat is absolutely not the wisest thing to do.
  • April2018mom
    April2018mom Posts: 2,868 Connected
    Don’t use the recording to threaten them. It is not a crime but it could be seen as a civilian case. Theoretically while you can record the phone call be aware that you are not allowed to share it. 
  • MW9
    MW9 Member Posts: 19 Courageous
    I wouldn’t use the call recording as a threat, that’s of course not my intention, it would be simply as a means to gain evidence that the DWP has revised their decision incase they deny it or don’t admit to it during the tribunal.

    That being said, the evidence that goes against their decision that’s already been given should be more than sufficient. 

Brightness

Complete our feedback form and tell us how we can make the community better.

Do you need advice on your energy costs?


Scope’s Disability Energy Support service is open to any disabled household in England or Wales in which one or more disabled people live. You can get free advice from an expert adviser on managing energy debt, switching tariffs, contacting your supplier and more. Find out more information by visiting our
Disability Energy Support webpage.