Single Sex Toilets

Comments

  • ColonelBlink
    ColonelBlink Community Member Posts: 784 Pioneering

    Just looked in for the first time today, and i'm surprised nobody wanted to comment on this one. Not to worry!

  • chiarieds
    chiarieds Community Member Posts: 17,398 Championing

    I can understand the concern where women have experienced former abuse, & therefore the reluctance to admit someone assigned male at birth to share a toilet with themselves as 'biological' females, but doubt the majority of these pose any risk at all.

    On the flip side of this, my eldest grandchild was assigned female at birth, but when they became 18 a few years ago identified that they felt male, which we've all as a family happily accepted. At work they were offered to use a 'disabled' toilet, & perhaps if more of these were publicly offered, that could be a solution for all.

  • ColonelBlink
    ColonelBlink Community Member Posts: 784 Pioneering
    edited May 22

    When both my daughters were at High School, their school had only unisex toilets. They knew nothing else, and didn't understand the fuss.

    As adults, I suppose they have perhaps changed their views, and appreciate how naive was their outlook. Life is complicated.

  • OverlyAnxious
    OverlyAnxious Community Member Posts: 6,026 Championing

    I can't open the link. The only options are to let the Guardian send my data to 139 places or to pay. Each to their own, but I'm not being forced into either of those choices. I do find it sad that 'news' companies operate in this way now. Just goes to show it's all about money, not about impartially providing all news for readers to make their own decisions.

    On the topic, this is one that I struggle with. I try to treat everyone equally. But the more time I spend on this forum, and the internet in general, it seems like people don't actually want to be treated equally. Some want to be treated as more important than others. This was highlighted by a large thread on Scope a few weeks ago. I found it very interesting to read. But also really struggled with it 'morally' as it just doesn't fit my idea of equality.

    The problem I have is that some being treated as more important obviously means others are treated as less important. Trans people, whether born male or female, are still people. I can (at least partly) understand the fear that women have around men. I experience fear around a lot of men myself. I don't have the strength to fight off any attackers. However, when it comes to toilets, I wonder where it ends. Do women also feel unsafe if a biological woman with a beard and an artificial appendage uses the ladies toilet? Do they feel unsafe if a lesbian uses the ladies toilet? Do they feel unsafe if a woman who has inherited masculine features uses the ladies toilet?

  • WelshBlue
    WelshBlue Community Member Posts: 1,210 Championing

    I hadn't seen the story or the thread, but after the Supreme Court ruling it was always going to happen

    People are going to argue blue on both sides … my views on everyone is; I'll treat you with respect until you disrespect me and mine. You can be whoever you want to be as long as you're not harming anyone else. Whilst I'd find it disconcerting stood by a woman with a bigger manhood than me … they're not harming me. (Not that I look)

    I'm a survivor of male on male trauma, and feel a lot more uncomfortable around men than I do around any Trans Person.

    As long as people don't argue with hate every opinion is valid ?

  • Bluebell21
    Bluebell21 Community Member Posts: 3,279 Championing
    edited May 23

    I think the whole design of Public Toilets is wrong. The fact that you have to go into a large room before you go into the cubicle is the problem.

    I hate Public Toilets but having Ulcerative Colitis I do not always have a choice but to use them.

    I would prefer all Public Toilets to be designed like Disabled Toilets where it is a room on its own with a wash basin and a mirror and a toilet of course. You go straight into it with a Radar key and it is for just one person.

    Just do away with the first big room and have individual small rooms with either Radar key access or have an attendant who you get a key off and return when you have finished with it. They could also clean the toilets when no one is using them. You could easily have three or four individual rooms next to each other so no more space would be needed.

    There would be no one left out then as all genders would use the same ones, and everyone would feel safe.

  • SheffieldMan1976
    SheffieldMan1976 Posts: 1,869 Connected

    And here in Sheffield, some of the Council run Toilets are so disgustingly unhygienic you don't want to go in even if you're busting, it's bad enough just for a wee but if you need to sit down for the ahem other end…

  • ColonelBlink
    ColonelBlink Community Member Posts: 784 Pioneering
  • ColonelBlink
    ColonelBlink Community Member Posts: 784 Pioneering

    I have been on "Comment Is Free" since 2010, and I've never paid them a penny. I suppose they have to raise revenue somehow, especially with the paper copy selling so poorly these days. I imagine you could read the gist of the story elsewhere on the Internet.

  • JanePS
    JanePS Community Member Posts: 12 Connected

    I'm less concerned about the bathroom issue and think it undermines the whole argument, I don't care who uses what toilet and everyone should be comfortable. This decision applies more widely to things like rape centres and women's / men's refuges and which seems more important.

  • ColonelBlink
    ColonelBlink Community Member Posts: 784 Pioneering
    edited 2:06PM

    I remember Isla Bryson, who in 2016 and 2019, r*ped two women whilst still a man, He was tried and charged in court, still a man.

    In 2020, Bryson came out as transgender, being placed on remand in a woman's prison, despite his gender still recorded as male!

    Bryson' claimed to have known he was transgender since aged 4, but both mother and estranged wife have expressed skepticism about this.