PIP, DLA and AA
If this is your first visit, check out the community guide. You will have to Join us or Sign in before you can post.

DLA to PIP

DinkysaurusDinkysaurus Member Posts: 36 Courageous
Hello everyone.
I have been on DLA lower rate care, higher rate mobility for 20 years. I had an indefinite award. My issues are physical. I don't have feeling in one leg and have referred pain in my good leg due to the work it has to do to compensate. I fall regularly ( just knocked my front teeth out recently from a fall ) and don't like to go out. and if I do then I always have someone with me. I also use crutches all the time. My bed is now downstairs and I need a commode too as our bathroom is upstairs. The staircase is too narrow for a lift. My daughter is my main carer. 
I received the letter to move from DLA to PIP 4 weeks ago. I completed the form and attached a letter from my GP. I went for my face to face assessment yesterday. The lady was nice and asked a question then typed what I answered ( I hope )  I was fine no concerns about it until now. I'm in panic mode. I don't know why. I think I told her everything. I called the DWP today for a copy of the assessment and they will send it out to me. 
I have read other peoples experiences and a lot of people with mental health issues really appear to be discriminated against. My issue will never get better and has worsened with time an will continue to do so. I'm 46 now and this was medical negligence that caused my disability 21 years ago. Its a wait for me now.  I also get ESA in the support group. 
If anyone has had similar experiences with lower limb mobility issues I would love to hear your experiences. 

Replies

  • atlas46atlas46 Member Posts: 827 Pioneering
    Hi @Dinkysaurus

    A very warm welcome.

    You will be able to see what level of benefit has been recommended, once you have the assessment report to hand.

    Over a million people have moved from DLA to PIP since 2013.

    We only hear of poor experiences on Internet forums.

    My PIP was fine and the assessor was kind and empathetic, I was awarded enhanced for both.

    My wife was allowed to speak and support throughout the assessment.

    Hope this helps.
  • DinkysaurusDinkysaurus Member Posts: 36 Courageous
    Hi Atlas46

    Thank you for your reply. Yes, you do seem to see a lot of the negative experiences. 
    For my ESA assessment, I was declined however I asked them to look at it again and got a phone call saying that the actual assessor's medical report did uphold my disability issues but the original decision maker had overruled it. However, they overturned that decision and am now in the support group. 
    I am not usually a worrier in general and wasn't until after this PIP face to face. Even though like I said it appeared to go well its a waiting game.
    As I was typing I have received a text to say that they have my report from Atos and will contact me with the decision. So Im keeping everything crossed. 
  • poppy123456poppy123456 Member Posts: 22,218 Disability Gamechanger
    Hi,

    If you live in the UK you can ring DWP to request a copy of the assessment report to be sent to you. This will give you some idea what the decision is likely to be because they mostly go with the recommendations in the report.
    Proud winner of the 2019 empowering others award. This award was given for supporting disabled people and their families for the benefit advice I have given to members here on the community.
  • atlas46atlas46 Member Posts: 827 Pioneering
    Hi

    I agree it is a very stressful period after your assessment till you get the formal award letter from the DWP.

    As previously explained when you get the report, you will be able to see what has been recommended.

    Is that an omen, that you got a text whilst typing on this thread!

    It takes about 6-8 weeks before payment for PIP kicks in.

    Keep us informed.





  • DinkysaurusDinkysaurus Member Posts: 36 Courageous
    @atlas46

    Can I just ask, please? The descriptor regarding mobility for the actual going out. I told them I don't like going out and don't do so unless it's needed. I don't go shopping etc as its obviously very painful with my condition and the after effects are also bad, but also someone is with me all the time due to the falls I have. So if I need to go out for example to the hospital or the assessment I have my 2 crutches and someone with me, usually my daughter. Would this score points? In addition to the actual walking as I describe below?
    The amount of time and distance I can walk is poor. The assessor told me that the 6-metre walk from the waiting room to her room was just under a minute. ( Obviously, timed me ) . I also told her that if I need to go upstairs which should be weekly for my bath ( believe me I'm like a 5-year old that makes up excuses not to! ) I have to go on my bottom.  She also asked if I drove. I told her no and she said before me " as its too much pain? " which is true. She asked how I got there. My son drove me. We live 500 metres from the assessment centre and as I told her that was bad enough. 
    She asked me to do movements sat in the chair. My leg is "dead " and doesnt move at all and she said " you certainly have no movement there have you"  
    Im so bad as I've been reading the terrible outcomes even with an understanding assessor like mine.
    I really hope I get awarded the points I deserve. 
  • atlas46atlas46 Member Posts: 827 Pioneering
    Hi

    The mobility is considered in two parts.

    1. Planning and following journeys.

    2. Moving around.

    From what you have described you should score in both.

    Interesting I had to undertake the musculoskeletal tests sat in the chair, for the same reason as you, numbness and pain in my left leg.

    Another factor that is also taken into account, can you do the activity in a safe, repeatedly and in timely manner.

    In other words without causing your problems to worsen or putting you at risk of harm.
    As in the falls you have mentioned.

    You should have the report within a few days.

    The best advice I can give, is don’t worry and try and relax.

    Keep us informed.

  • DinkysaurusDinkysaurus Member Posts: 36 Courageous
    @atlas46

    Thank you very much for your reply. 

    I will keep you informed. As soon as I receive the report, good or bad news I will let you know. 
  • April2018momApril2018mom Posts: 2,869 Member
    Not everyone will fail the tests for each activity. Remember that every condition is different. My son didn’t fail the tests for activity number 11 since I have no safety concerns. Some people who only have physical disabilities will fail the tests that are about mobility issues. Good luck. 
  • DinkysaurusDinkysaurus Member Posts: 36 Courageous
    @ilovecats thank you for your reply.

    The reason I asked is I need someone with me when I'm out due to falls that are frequent in the house and also when outside, For instance falling in the hospital and knocking my teeth out on the lift door.  In the 20 years with this, I have had countless falls and injuries. ( broken foot, ligament damage, head injury )
    So while I was fairly sure about the actual limitations on walking, I was unsure that needing someone with me at all times came under the other descriptor. Or is there no taking into account about actually needing someone with me on a journey?

    Thank you 
  • DinkysaurusDinkysaurus Member Posts: 36 Courageous
    @ilovecats

    It does make sense I understand now. Thank you very much.
  • davetdavet Member Posts: 77 Courageous
    hi
    I can very much relate to yourself, I too have lower limb issues following a stroke which was also due to medical negligence, my left leg is almost useless and like you I suffer pain in my right leg and hip with the extra work it has to do ( I did in fact send a letter from my GP confirming this) and I find it difficult to walk a short distance. initially I too was on DLA with a full mobility award then I was "invited" to apply for PIP and attended a face to face assessment which I too thought went well, however I received a copy of my report and was staggered at some of its contents and the exclusion of some points, I was asked by the assessor to cross my left leg casually over my right knee without using my hands this I did however I almost fell off the chair doing it, the assessor himself even said "whoa be careful there, we dont want you more disabled" yet there was nothing in the report about this incident at all, in fact he reported that I was able to carry out all movements he asked me to do, he also reported that on completion of the assessment I bent down and picked my bag up from the floor, what he failed to mention was that I was sat down at the time, following this report my benefit was reduced. I personally was disgusted by the way the DWP seemed to try anything in order to reduce my benefit, I had told them that I have to use a taxi to the local supermarket and back, so they decided that  as I was able to walk to a taxi, I was able to walk normally and  when I sent them photographs showing that the taxi is able to stop within six foot of my front door and the taxi rank for coming back home was actually within ten feet of the supermarket door they completely ignored it,  despite reconsideration they still would not move on their decision. I then took it to a tribunal where more consideration was given to the proof I had provided along with noting a point which the assessor had overlooked and my claim was increased, I still lost my full mobility award, but to be honest by that time I had had enough of trying to fight them  
  • atlas46atlas46 Member Posts: 827 Pioneering
    ilovecats said:
    atlas46 said:
    Hi

    The mobility is considered in two parts.

    1. Planning and following journeys.

    2. Moving around.

    From what you have described you should score in both.

    Interesting I had to undertake the musculoskeletal tests sat in the chair, for the same reason as you, numbness and pain in my left leg.

    Another factor that is also taken into account, can you do the activity in a safe, repeatedly and in timely manner.

    In other words without causing your problems to worsen or putting you at risk of harm.
    As in the falls you have mentioned.

    You should have the report within a few days.

    The best advice I can give, is don’t worry and try and relax.

    Keep us informed.

    I disagree. Activity 12 yes, but not Activity 11. 

    Activity 11 will only score if there is a cognitive, visual or epilepsy related restriction or violence/safety concerns. Mental health will only score if there is overwhelming psychological distress present or someone is actively suicidal with plans.
    Hi @ilovecats

    I disagree with you, activity 1 does apply for @Dinkysaurus in mobility.

    We just have to wait till @Dinkysaurus gets a copy of his PIP report, to see who is right.

    I have already drafted my victory speech!

    Best wishes.

  • poppy123456poppy123456 Member Posts: 22,218 Disability Gamechanger
    Falls arising from a physical disability will score under activity 12.

    If the falls arise from a sensory or cognitive impairment then the claimant would score under activity 11 for safety. As Dinkysaurus is claiming for just a physical condition then they won't score under activity 11.
    Proud winner of the 2019 empowering others award. This award was given for supporting disabled people and their families for the benefit advice I have given to members here on the community.
  • DinkysaurusDinkysaurus Member Posts: 36 Courageous
    Good morning

    @atlas46 @ilovecats

    I will say that I am on anxiety medication. I explained that it's due to feeling anxious and have panic attacks on occasion about going out mainly as I'm embarrassed about the falls and worrying if I can manage. She asked if the medication worked. I was honest and said sometimes yes but not all the time. I did have CPN support in the past for depression and was on an antidepressant but therapy helped this so that was discontinued but the anxiety remains. 

    And again thank you for your input all this is helping me understand.
  • atlas46atlas46 Member Posts: 827 Pioneering
    Hi @ilovecats

    There are a number of grounds.

    If @Dinkysaurus is considered an honest and reliable historian, of which I have no doubt whatsoever.

    He explains he is always accompanied by someone, when undertaking a journey.

    He has provided information about falls, including actual injuries being caused (knocked out front tooth).

    The fact that I was awarded descriptor b in activity 1 and descriptor e in activity 2.

    My issues are almost a mirror image of what has been reported.

    For the benefit of doubt I quote from my report, what the assessor wrote to justify her descriptor choice, in activity 1.

    ”He reports ongoing spatial awareness problems when walking. He plans routes of journeys with support from his wife for their safety. This is consistent with informal observations noting he required support from his wife to attend the assessment centre. Additionally his further evidence of chronic back pain and spatial awareness difficulties indicates the probability of requiring prompts to reliably undertake a journey. It is reasonable to assume he requires prompts with the task demands.”

    Hope this helps.

    PS

    Victory speech now drafted!!
  • atlas46atlas46 Member Posts: 827 Pioneering
    ilovecats said:
    I’m not going to get into a back and forth. I’m pleased that your spatial awareness issues were rightly recognised for Activity 11. 

    The OP does not indicate any sort of cognitive, sensory or issues relating to spatial awareness so they cannot score for them. 

    They are accompanied for physical reasons relating to falls.
    Although he reports anxiety, this is relating to the act of falling and though he mentions panic attacks, in the absence of further information, he does not describe any symptoms associated with overwhelming psychological distress. 

    I’m fairly confident that what they describe is relating to a physical condition so it should be scored under activity 12. Going on what the OP describes, he should be awarded 12E (enhanced mobility).

    I don’t know if you’re aware but I used to be a PIP assessor and I’m fairly confident in the advice I am giving.
    Hi @ilovecats

    We have to wait for @Dinkysaurus gets his assessment report to conclude matters.

    Yes I did know you where a PIP assessor, as you have repeated that in a number of posts.

    You have also told us you gained lawful employment as an NHS paramedic.

    I don’t know if you are aware that I worked in various UK ambulance services for more than thirty years, ten of which was the highest level.

    You might not be aware, that I was the lead researcher on behalf of the Stroke Association, looking at residual disability post stroke. This was a 5 year research project, the findings of which are still in clinical practice today.

    You also might like to know, I represented the UK ambulances for over 5 years, at the Royal College of Surgeons (Edinburgh).

    I am also the proud holder of HRH Long Service & Good Conduct Medal.

    Never trust a book by its cover.
  • DinkysaurusDinkysaurus Member Posts: 36 Courageous
    I have been reading all your comments...thank you as always. 

    @atlas46 and @ilovecats thank you both for the service you have to the NHS. All the workers are worth their weight in gold. 

    I had a fall today although good news its a pulled muscle in my back so nothing serious just another twinge to add to my ever-growing collection. 

    Just to play devil's advocate here but there is a chance I could get 0 points. I've seen this a few times especially the DLA to PIP changes like mine is. Even though after reading through all the advice regarding filling in the form, concentrating on how it affects me rather than my actual illness, having a comprehensive statement from my GP  and the assessor who was very kind and patient and I didn't feel like I was being tricked. 

    The thing I am a little worried about. Things keep coming back what was said in the assessment... she said are you under any consultants now? So remember this happened over 20 years ago. Over the years I have seen a Neurologist, Orthopaedics, physio, and a CPN.  The Neurologist did nerve conduction studies at yearly intervals with no improvement to the dead nerve. Orho told me that that the pressure on my hip and knee on my good side would worsen as I got older and I would probably be returning to see them in the future with more than likely joint replacements. So there is nothing further the hospital could do for me. I explained this to the assessor she nodded and typed some more. 

    I am not the sort of person who would pester for another referral from my GP to the hospital. This is how I am and will still for the remainder of my life. I have had 20 years to get used to this fact, Obviously if it gets to the point I cannot use my " good " knee or hip then I will go to the doctor. 

    Totally honest in my opinion I think I should get standard care and enhanced mobility reading the descriptors. But like you have said I will have to wait. 

    As a side note. I had a Scope person visit today they were canvassing the neighbourhood. Very friendly chap.
  • April2018momApril2018mom Posts: 2,869 Member
    You did your best to answer questions. This is all you can do. Don’t get stressed. If you have any other questions don’t hesitate to ask questions us. 
  • DinkysaurusDinkysaurus Member Posts: 36 Courageous
    I have my assessment report back.
     Care = Standard
    Mobility = Standard.

    I will be doing a mandatory reconsideration when I get the final decision.  
    I had to do that for ESA too which was successful.

    I will concentrate on where I disagree with the descriptors. However, she said I " arrived for the assessment alone ".  As stated above my son drove me my daughter accompanied me. My daughter would not stay with me in the room as the reason for my injury was during her birth and she gets so upset hearing how I struggle, blaming herself. And Im sorry but Im not subjecting my daughter to a circus performance that will upset her. This went against me.  She sat me down in the consultation room and I explained why she would wait outside. The nurse then called her back in afterwards to help me up and get back out. 
    So yes this does seems like I'm a bit aggrieved with the assessor but its something I need to add in my MR.  As it directly affects my ability to manage alone.

    With regards to care... I got 8 points.  The bathing and toileting issues will be in my MR. I said above that I thought I would get standard care however I feel the 2 main ones for bathing and toilet were marked well down. Especially the bathing one. 

    With regards to mobility 10 points ....  As I said above it was a short walk she said is that about as far as you can do? ( approx 6 metres ) I said yes she said it took you just under a minute. She gave me 10 for mobility stating that I can walk a full minute. I did but it was only 6 metres then I sat down!. She never mentioned just how far I walked. 

    My daughter was pleased she said I looked well kept and of average build as my daughter does the cooking and sees to my dressing needs. She says at least Im doing ok. 

    I won't turn it into a witch hunt against the assessor and will stick to challenging the descriptors. I now have time to get this all down while waiting for the official decision then I can do the MR. 
  • DinkysaurusDinkysaurus Member Posts: 36 Courageous
    I would be really grateful if @poppy123456 could give me advice.

    Thank you @ilovecats
  • poppy123456poppy123456 Member Posts: 22,218 Disability Gamechanger
    Hi,

    I know it's very frustrating when you see things written that didn't happen but the DWP or the Tribunal won't be interested in any lies told in the report. Any complaints about the report should be sent to the health assessment providers, details are on their website.

    You should concentrate on where you think you should have scored those points and your reasons why. Adding 2-3 examples of what happened the last time you attempted that activity for each descriptor that applies to you.

    Do bare in mind that you will always score points for using an aid if it is medically reasonable for you to do so. If assistance is needed then you will have to prove why it's not reasonable for you to use an aid safely and reliably.

    This link maybe useful and i'd advise you to have a read through as it will give you more understanding about what the descriptors mean. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/personal-independence-payment-assessment-guide-for-assessment-providers/pip-assessment-guide-part-2-the-assessment-criteria

    You have 1 month from the date of the decision to request the MR. Good luck.

    Proud winner of the 2019 empowering others award. This award was given for supporting disabled people and their families for the benefit advice I have given to members here on the community.
  • cristobalcristobal Member Posts: 968 Disability Gamechanger
    @Dinkysaurus - there was some discussion about walking on another thread.

    You should only be assessed as being able to manage any of the descriptors if you can do so 'reliably' (as @ilovecats says)

    If you are taking nearly a minute to walk such a short distance this is not  'within a reasonable time period' and therefore not 'reliable' so you should score 12 points.

    If the assessor has written what you have posted above then then it seems that they've just made simple mistake (unless they don't know the guidelines)

    As @poppy123456 says no need to say anyone's lying but for MR just point out that if they look at their own guidelines they will see that they have made a mistake...

    Good luck...
  • DinkysaurusDinkysaurus Member Posts: 36 Courageous
    @poppy123456 @cristobel

    Thank you for your replies.

    Yes I wont be saying she lied Im really not that sort of person even if I disagree with what she has written. 

    As you can see in my previous posts walking at any time is unreliable the number of falls I have. My bedroom is downstairs ( was the dining room ) and walking 5 metres into the living room or vice Versa I fall, and I mean on a regular basis. Hence where my anxiety for going out comes from. Imagine your leg is just dangly and you cannot feel where it is. Not only do I have the pain from my good knee and hip I also need to try and swing the bad leg...this is where I overbalance. 

    I would like to ask.... as I said Im downstairs now the bathroom upstairs. I have a commode in my room. I use this all the time. And I really dont want to go into detail here but lets say I cannot clean and need help with toilet needs. All of which was explained. Also on occasion, I have had incontinence as I haven't got to the commode in time. I was awarded 0 for toilet needs.  Is the commode classed as an aid?  This was on my form and my GP letter that was sent in and I explained this to the nurse in the f2f. There was no mention of the commode at all in her report.

    Thank you guys...


  • DinkysaurusDinkysaurus Member Posts: 36 Courageous
    Oooo and another question...sorry,

    My MR,,,is it best to phone it or send in the post?

    Thank you again
  • April2018momApril2018mom Posts: 2,869 Member
    I would send them it by post. That way you can be sure that they will receive it. 
  • cristobalcristobal Member Posts: 968 Disability Gamechanger
    @Dinkysaurus - I think I read somewhere that going to the toilet doesn't include actually getting there so, if the commode is because you can't get upstairs I don't think that counts.

    I'll try and find it...but in the meantime I imagine that someone else will know for certain...
  • cristobalcristobal Member Posts: 968 Disability Gamechanger
    @dinkysauraus - this is what the guidelines say...

    Descriptor A should be appropriate for claimants who use a commode due to limited mobility (and therefore have difficulty mobilising to the toilet) but otherwise can manage their toilet needs or incontinence.

    IIRC 'A' = 0 points...
  • poppy123456poppy123456 Member Posts: 22,218 Disability Gamechanger
    Always put the MR in writing. If the reason you have the commode is because you can't get to the bathroom because of your mobility problems then i agree with @cristobal it won't be taken into consideration.

    Lots of people think that they should have scored x amount of points or they should have scored higher than they did in certain descriptors but it's not always possible. This is the reason i posted that link above for you to have a read. I agree it's very long but well worth spending a little time reading as much as you can to give yourself a better understanding.
    Proud winner of the 2019 empowering others award. This award was given for supporting disabled people and their families for the benefit advice I have given to members here on the community.
  • DinkysaurusDinkysaurus Member Posts: 36 Courageous
    Thank you once again for your help.

    I will keep you updated as we go along. I could be here quite a while on the forum. Which is no hardship as you all have been very helpful and its very much appreciated.
  • cristobalcristobal Member Posts: 968 Disability Gamechanger

    Lots of people think that they should have scored x amount of points or they should have scored higher than they did in certain descriptors but it's not always possible. This is the reason i posted that link above for you to have a read. I agree it's very long but well worth spending a little time reading as much as you can to give yourself a better understanding.
    Fully agree ...
  • DinkysaurusDinkysaurus Member Posts: 36 Courageous
    @ilovecats thank you for your explanation.

    I really can't go into my toilet habits here, Im sure no one really wants to know but your second paragraph is more my situation.
    I will look closely at Activity 12.

    Thank you
  • poppy123456poppy123456 Member Posts: 22,218 Disability Gamechanger
    @ilovecats thank you for your explanation.

    I really can't go into my toilet habits here, Im sure no one really wants to know but your second paragraph is more my situation.
    I will look closely at Activity 12.

    Thank you
    Then scoring 0 for toilet needs is correct.
    Proud winner of the 2019 empowering others award. This award was given for supporting disabled people and their families for the benefit advice I have given to members here on the community.
  • twonkertwonker Posts: 617 Member
    ilovecats said:
    @ilovecats thank you for your explanation.

    I really can't go into my toilet habits here, Im sure no one really wants to know but your second paragraph is more my situation.
    I will look closely at Activity 12.

    Thank you
    If you have a physical condition that causes restrictions when sitting and standing or pain when attempting to do so then this can be considered, think about how you rise from the toilet. Do you have to hold onto a sink, radiator, hand on the wall. That would indicate a need for aids.

    so would not being able to manage your hygiene effectively, e.g putting your hand ‘downstairs’ if that is restricted then again, aids can be considered. 
    So having to have a commode downstairs because getting to the toilet is almost impossible as it is upstairs = 0 points. Yet already having a downstairs AND an upstairs toilet that both have a frame fitted around them would score 2 points!

    I presume that not having a commode downstairs due to the lack of any privacy (open room kitchen/dining/lounge), and the inability to get upstairs to the only toilet and consequently would soil themselves would get how many points? The only reason I ask is that my elder brother was in this position until he died last year - he was continually soiling his clothes and was awarded 0 points for his PIP claim/review just before he died. It was said that irrespective of the room layout his walking ability he should have worn nappies which he refused to do (to proud).

    Never thought that I would want to discuss bodily functions.

     
  • DinkysaurusDinkysaurus Member Posts: 36 Courageous
    @twonker

    I am so sorry for the loss of your brother. 

    Yes I have also soiled myself trying to get to the toilet hence why I have a commode. I also cannot stand and clean myself. My daughter cleans as I stand with my crutches, I cannot stand on one leg I don't have balance not to mention the deteriorating condition of my knee and hip on the good side which will no way hold my weight for that length of time. Then, of course, I cannot pull my lower clothing up either. 

    I go upstairs once a week for a bath. This involves going up the stairs on my bottom. However, as I told the assessor and my GP explained this too this now is too painful and I refuse most times it just makes me anxious and panicky. Also, this was explained. 

    When I do get a bath they assessed me 2 points I need an aid or appliance. Remember I cannot bend. So i step in with my good leg while my daughter supports the bad leg, then she lifts the bad leg over into the bath * this is where I usually give a squeal of pain. Lowering into the bath she stands behind me at the end of the bath with her arms under mine and lowers me down.  I can wash my hair and top of body but she washes my lower body as I cannot bend...this was also confirmed in the report I couldnt bend. So I dont understand why I didnt get the help with bathing below the waist. 

    The same with the dressing I can do the top half but again I can't bend ( as the assessor noted ) but expects me to dress myself below the waist. 

    My daughter has given up so much for me shes amazing. She cares for me fulltime, and my son does when she is having some time off. I cant even get them Carer's Allowance and look how much they do for me. She is 21 she has done this since being 11 when my condition deteriorated. 

    Like advised I can only go through each descriptor and give examples of what happens when I do things . 



  • April2018momApril2018mom Posts: 2,869 Member
    That’s all you can do. That and blindly hope for the best. Hang in there. 
  • DinkysaurusDinkysaurus Member Posts: 36 Courageous
    @Ilikecats

    Wouldnt I be entitled to needs help getting in or out of the bath?  There is no way on earth I can manage getting in or out n my own with appliances. I would still need help with appliances. 

    Im sorry for the questions but I want to accurate in what I will write. If I see that what she said makes sense to you all and the reason why she will have gave me her scores then obviously I wont contest that element if I see where you are coming from. 

    I will be disputing the distance and timing of walking. If not only as I can't do it repetitively, safely and in a timeframe,  Nevermind the distance and timing of it that she must have been mistaken. 

    @April2018mom

    Thank you Im hanging in there... your help and support work wonders to keep the morale going. I could easily sit, cry and give up, but I will carry on. 
  • poppy123456poppy123456 Member Posts: 22,218 Disability Gamechanger
    No, not if they think you can reasonably use an aid, that's what you'll score points for. If you can't reasonably use an aid you have to prove why it's not safe for you to do so and what happened the last time you used an aid.
    Proud winner of the 2019 empowering others award. This award was given for supporting disabled people and their families for the benefit advice I have given to members here on the community.
  • twonkertwonker Posts: 617 Member
     you have to prove why it's not safe for you to do so and what happened the last time you used an aid.
    I'm not disputing what you are saying but there has to be some sort of acceptance here. How can it be possible to prove why it's not safe? What sort of evidence would swing that?
    And as for explaining what happened the last time this imaginary aid was used  is impossible. If you don't have this type of aid then what? How would the poster know what did happen if it never happened?

    To me there is about as much supposition going on here as an assessor does.
  • poppy123456poppy123456 Member Posts: 22,218 Disability Gamechanger
    edited May 2019
    I think we've covered this many times in the past ....
    Proud winner of the 2019 empowering others award. This award was given for supporting disabled people and their families for the benefit advice I have given to members here on the community.
  • DinkysaurusDinkysaurus Member Posts: 36 Courageous
    @poppy123456

    On the report from my doctor ( I was going to photo the paragraph but dint no how to upload )  he wrote...

    " She lives downstairs in her house. She and her husband cannot afford to move to more suitable premises. She does not have the option of having a stairlift due to the position of the stairs, "  ( we did have someone from adaptations come to look. ) 

    So I presume this would have been an aid/appliance and the only option I would have for the stairs. I already have handrails added to both sides but I'm unable to go up that way.  

    The only thing about whether its safe is I have on numerous times fallen getting in the bath over the years and before I reverted to going upstairs on my bottom I have also had my fair share of tumbles there too. 

    Its so frustrating trying to explain. I know it needs to be done for the MR and I'm happy I got my assessment report well ahead of the final decision so I have time to get my head around it all and do the most comprehensive one I can. 
  • DinkysaurusDinkysaurus Member Posts: 36 Courageous
    I submitted everything with my application. Including three reports of hospital admissions that were a result of falling. My physio, neurologist, ortho surgeon, the CPN I was under for years all the letters that they sent to my GP about their findings. My nerve conduction studies I had at yearly intervals showing there were no signs of the nerves working at all. My GP records are all to do with my condition since 1998. I have never needed to visit him for any other reason at all.  
    There are other things on the care award that I will also dispute. As they are of a sensitive nature and private I cannot go into them,
    The mobility side the assessor did contradict herself, by saying what I could do by marking the descriptor but in her comments said something else. I mean its a blatant difference. I really don't think she was lying at all. It's such a glaringly obvious difference. 
    I will concentrate on the descriptors I need more evidence with examples of when it happened what happened. Safely and repeatedly are a big issue with my mobility. 
    I'm still waiting for my decision although I'm sure I won't be one of the lucky 20% that doesnt go along with the assessor. Having said that for my ESA it did, I think I have had my fair share of luck with over rulings at this stage. 
    I have also started a diary as advised. Im not expecting my decision for a few weeks yet. Then it will be MR time Im sure.
  • poppy123456poppy123456 Member Posts: 22,218 Disability Gamechanger
    edited May 2019
    They mostly go with the report, it's very rare for them to against it. I'm not sure where you got the 20% figure from for going against the report. 19% of MR decisions change, is that what you mean?
    Proud winner of the 2019 empowering others award. This award was given for supporting disabled people and their families for the benefit advice I have given to members here on the community.
  • DinkysaurusDinkysaurus Member Posts: 36 Courageous
    Yes ...sorry. 
    Im aware its rare for them to go against the report. 
Sign in or join us to comment.