Green Paper Discussion (from 24th March, 2025)

1525355575863

Comments

  • Bigboblee50
    Bigboblee50 Online Community Member Posts: 41 Contributor

    Yep the old Deserving/undeserving argument

  • Wibbles
    Wibbles Online Community Member Posts: 3,128 Championing

    Did I read somewhere that those who are unaffected by these cuts (ie medically - the worst) may receive increased benefits ?

    If this is the EXTREMELY UNFAIR way ahead - how do they calculate the savings ?

  • gamer1
    gamer1 Online Community Member Posts: 81 Empowering
    edited April 2025

    I suspect that is government speak like when they say you would be better off on benefits while in work.

    Oh, they will make plenty of money from this reform don't you worry about that. It will be in the 100s of billions over the course of the next few decades because they are reforming this for future claimants also not just the people who are on it now.

    They will make so much money that they will have enough to pass around as toilet paper in their government parties. They will be laughing and enjoying going to concerts and holidays, eating in nice restaurants, going to events, dancing and partying, and making more and more money while we will be suffering and worrying everyday about money. We won't let it happen. They can not get away with it.

  • sarah_lea12
    sarah_lea12 Online Community Member Posts: 440 Empowering

    Even the most severely disabled as they put it may not get the 4 points so that reply from the MP was pointless .

  • Girl_No1
    Girl_No1 Online Community Member Posts: 413 Trailblazing
    edited April 2025

    I think they mean those who currently do not receive/have not applied for PIP may meet a higher criteria (payment) than they currently receive via only LCWRA when they are forced to apply/be reviewed under the one-assessment process,

    But, as I'm not a Tory of any shade (red or blue) I'm probably wrong.

    However, you can bet your sweet booty the first person to whom this happens will receive wall-to-wall, 24/7 media coverage to allow the Red Tories to pretend their 'moral crusade' is justified.

  • jasray
    jasray Online Community Member Posts: 1 Listener

    Trump has EVERYTHING to do with losing our benefits. He is the reason that Europe and UK have to spend billions more on defence. Disability benefits will help toward this. He is also about to wipe Trillions off the world markets, making companies less valuable and unable to expand like the want. This will make unemployment balloon which means the Government will now have another problem to economically deal with. Disability is an easy target as we are only a small percent of the population and this makes them expendable! Higher taxes effects a much higher percent of the population so that will be a last resort. Taxing the rich is out of the question because they have the money to find the loopholes or leave the country!

  • bton1968
    bton1968 Online Community Member Posts: 156 Empowering

    My wife receives a 4pt award for preparing a meal so that's one consolation .…

    But she only receives 2pts for mixing with other people and 2pts for making budgeting decisions when I believe they should have been 4pt awards.

    At her next review (2027) can I contest these 2pt awards ?

    I like many others haven't contested the 2pts because overall she was awarded enough pts for the higher care component of pip .

    It's a belt and braces approach but the more 4pt categories she scores in the better as a safety buffer.

    Thanks in advance

  • WhatThe
    WhatThe Online Community Member, Scope Member Posts: 4,988 Championing
    edited April 2025

    bigbob,

    Parliament Disclaimer: this e-mail is confidential to the intended recipient. If you have received it in error, please notify the sender and delete it from your system. Any unauthorised use, disclosure, or copying is not permitted.

  • noonebelieves
    noonebelieves Online Community Member Posts: 706 Championing
    edited April 2025

    “Wolves in sheep's clothing comes to mind!”

    Thanks @jul1aorways…However,with these lot-They’ve just been Wolves all along the way…. And have turned out to be Blood ..oh “Money Thirsty Merciless Vampires”

  • Santosha12
    Santosha12 Online Community Member Posts: 3,119 Championing

    @jasray 100% /totally agree with you, sadly.

  • Doglover2
    Doglover2 Online Community Member Posts: 333 Empowering

    I went through five dla assessments all with doctors i might add, before I got indefinite. Then forced onto pip.. zero points. Like many seem to get, so went to tribunal. They watched my every move, sent me out while they went through my notes, this lady springs up next to us, starts chatting, now I'm not great to say the least in social situations, so my mum had a few words with her in general conversation, this is what she said... "This is my 13th tribunal , I'm not letting them away with anything ,look at all my evidence,see all those cameras, watching us like hawks they are. ! All this in A very loud voice. I swear when I thought about it later she was put there on purpose to see what way I'd react. If I'd engage etc. Best bit is,about 18 mths later a similar thing happened to a friend. Anyway got my pip back. For three years,Second time 2 points,another tribunal only paper based, 3yrs again, third time 4 points, did and MR, got it again onthat for four yrs, due a review very soon. I'd rather eat rusty nails. The stress is unreal. Esp when the assessor inthe first instance couldn't even look up from the computer and the other two phone assessments were a total farce too. Lies ,untruths ,made up stories,whatever you want to call them.... what willit be like now with this 4 points nonsense. Dreading beyond dread, as last assessment nearly ended me.

  • noonebelieves
    noonebelieves Online Community Member Posts: 706 Championing

    I hear you, @Catherine21 and you’re absolutely right!

    It does feel outrageous that they seem to be getting away with it, but I genuinely believe they only will if we stay silent. That’s why I feel it’s so important we keep pushing back, especially through these live consultations. Even if people are struggling to respond to all the 20 questions, they should try to focus on the most relevant ones, like PIP and UC , Work , whichever affects them!

    Although they recommend adding your views under each question in the link, I feel it may be easier to voice your concerns via email in a narrative style(own words!), save them bit by bit (within your energy levels), and email them to consultation.pathwaystowork@dwp.gov.uk once complete. It might not feel like much, but every voice adds so much weight in a democratic society. And if we don’t speak up in this live consultation, they’ll just say “nobody objected.” and could potentially have the upper hand.

    If 16 million people stay quiet, thinking it’s somebody else’s or Charities businesses, it will only benefit the Liebour lot in this instance. I honestly don’t see any other way out of this. In my mind, I view it like a massive Individualised Mandatory Reconsideration request.

    From what I’ve seen, this lot seem ready to push through anything, no matter how senseless or cruel…..even if it means fighting it legally. But I still have hope, especially when people like you & everyone here are speaking out. That does make a difference.

    Best wishes, Catherine! Please do look after yourself. Nothing is over…There’s still so much hope! 🤗

  • Martinp
    Martinp Online Community Member Posts: 249 Empowering

    Thinking of you Danny123

    Take good care and glad your mum coming home.

  • Santosha12
    Santosha12 Online Community Member Posts: 3,119 Championing

    @Danny123 Really pleased your mum is coming home tomorrow and wishing her well for her ongoing recovery 🙏 take good care of yourself too.

  • JasonRA
    JasonRA Online Community Member Posts: 310 Championing

    Hello all.

    I tried to take time away just to get away from worrying but here I am on a sleepless night worrying.

    My thoughts are:

    That these cuts and changes will be disproportionately effecting disabled people surely none of it will be seen as lawful? Thing is I suspect Starmer intends to pass PIP/Universal Credit's changes as a money legislation (mentioned on here) meaning the Lords can't amend it and so it becomes the law of the land.

    This PIP 4 Point Rule is nothing to do with money, surely that requires a different legislation and or a Green/White Paper?

    The Green Paper and the subsequent White Paper may face legal challenges and possible amendments by the Lords. I think it's there where legal apparatus will be used.

    Lastly I thought Labour would be the least worst option, they're even more worse than I imagined.

  • noonebelieves
    noonebelieves Online Community Member Posts: 706 Championing

    Wishes for your mum’s ongoing recovery . Take care @Danny123

  • [Deleted User]
    [Deleted User] Posts: 1,170 Championing
    The user and all related content has been deleted.
  • [Deleted User]
    [Deleted User] Posts: 1,170 Championing
    The user and all related content has been deleted.
  • gamer1
    gamer1 Online Community Member Posts: 81 Empowering
    edited April 2025

    Well, what they have released so far is not very clear. WCA is going to be scrapped for LCWRA but merged to PIP so all on LCWRA and PIP will have to do the new merged WCA. So EITHER they will have to remove mental health descriptors from the merged WCA to get rid of most mental health claimants from their benefits or add mental health descriptors to facilitate the most severe mental health conditions in the merged WCA.

    PIP is really meant to be for mobility conditions and the costs for mobility. It does not really cater for mental health. Remembering that they have added the 4 point daily living making it harder for everyone anyway. This is not right. They have to give us more information on what the WCA is going to be whether they are going to facilitate mental health or not and whether they care about conditions that are NOT COVERED at all even now by the WCA.

    If they are going to use the current PIP WCA just adding the 4 point in one descriptor for daily living to qualify it will mean EVERY mental health claimant will not qualify and many mobility claimants will not qualify. They need to give more info and be clear with it.

This discussion has been closed.