Scope's reply to the governments planned concessions to the green paper.

1679111254

Comments

  • secretsquirrel1
    secretsquirrel1 Online Community Member Posts: 2,052 Championing

    Hi Amaya

    I won at upper tribunal after having to go to the upper tier for permission as the tribunal had erred in law . I won and my pip was reviewed as normal after 3 years plus 2 years back pay . I guess it must be random and again something that’s unfair within the system. I find too much of claiming pip down to luck .

  • Hopeless
    Hopeless Online Community Member, Scope Member Posts: 1,004 Pioneering

    sorry, I have no idea as I had to tick the box that I didn’t have any of the ID they wanted

  • Ironside1990
    Ironside1990 Online Community Member Posts: 397 Pioneering

    Even Liz Kendall has said vouchers will never happen as it would take autonomy away from claimants.

  • Karl99
    Karl99 Online Community Member Posts: 15 Contributor

    I’m in the same boat, on contribution ESA with UC top up. From what I’ve been told, this is being entirely scrapped and in its place will be the new Employment Insurance that is a much reduced payment and for a limited time of 6-12months. I presume any new PIP application will be regarded as a NEW claim and subject to the 4point rule, because we are not currently claiming PIP. Basically we’re being thrown under a bus. ….and those claiming PIP think they have something to worry about!!!!

  • Ross1975
    Ross1975 Online Community Member Posts: 890 Championing

    Exactly what is the concession for people on LCWRA?

    I keep hearing that we're protected which is very vague, protected in what way? It was already decided before the concessions that people already on LCWRA won't have the health element halved (unless after April next year you get thrown off it and then reclaim which will then make you a new claimant), so it's something else, but what exactly?

  • Danny123
    Danny123 Online Community Member Posts: 223 Empowering
    edited June 2025

    I've heard that cbesa is getting merged with job seekers to create employment insurance....

    But I'm not sure that would apply to people in the support group of ESA and the UC lcwra group (especially existing claimants ) .... I don't see how they could do that to be honest , also they have said repeatedly that existing claimants who claim the health element will be protected

    The 4 point criteria is what worries me because technically we will be new pip claims , but surely as we are existing claimants of ESA support group and UC we will be assessed under the current criteria

    I think all we can do is wait and see what and what doesn't get voted through next week , then we will know what's what ....

    Yes I'm the same as you cbesa every two weeks 281 pounds

    Then end of the month just over 800 but they deduct 609 pounds from my ESA , leaves me with 214 ..... So about 775 a month

    I agree it's shocking this has gone under the radar as it will effect alot of people , they haven't been clear about this at all

  • Danny123
    Danny123 Online Community Member Posts: 223 Empowering

    I don't think cbesa / new style ESA will merge with job seekers until after the WCA is scrapped anyway .... So really I would think we will just keep getting reassessed under the current WCA until 2028 , we will know along time before that what were up against

  • Trevor_PIP
    Trevor_PIP Online Community Member Posts: 1,224 Championing
    edited June 2025

    I agree with posts from @mrsBB and @MW123 I don't trust this government either. Current PIP claimants will keep their PIP? PIP claimants are losing their PIP now, I know of a young man with mental health issues who was on PIP Enhanced both elements, now is on zero and a parent has lost the Carers allowance too. Members post on this forum getting zero points from assessments who are on Enhanced PIP rates.... I don't read about any of the changes, whatever is voted through will mean nothing if they want people of UC and PIP. Assessors or Decision Managers will just reduce the points which they are doing right now and always done!! It is a money saving exercise as in 2020 there were only 2m claiming PIP from it's start in 2013 (I think). Now just under 5 years later there are now 3.7m claiming PIP, 1.7m more in less than 5 years and over and after lockdowns. Face to face appointments stopped what I went through.... Something is amiss whatever way you look at it. Reeves wants this voted through and then it will start, if she goes for more tax off working people experts reckon there will be trouble in this country. Currently you don't have have to earn that much now to be paying 40% tax, that does upset working people already! The country is getting to be a joke, if it was not so serious! That's my thoughts on the issue.

  • michael57
    michael57 Online Community Member Posts: 2,466 Championing

    Haha don't use either I did consider getting a trampoline to help me clean the upstairs windows but she who must be obeyed put her foot down

  • secretsquirrel1
    secretsquirrel1 Online Community Member Posts: 2,052 Championing

    Hi chiaried,

    It says AR1 but not the numbers at the bottom. It’s 32 pages including the information on how to fill it in . I t does say not to send a GP letter of support but I’m no longer under hospital specialist due to there being no treatment for ME and fibromyalgia. Plus the other conditions I have . Should I just get one anyway ? The Dr I see isn’t my named Dr at the surgery so I don’t want them asking someone who hasn’t seen me .

  • geckobat
    geckobat Online Community Member Posts: 195 Empowering

    This is very confusing to me because regardless of the concession, if they scrap the WCA as planned, won't any reassessment be under new PIP rules for LCWRA too? They had said the reassessments should be running properly again too I thought, so it sounded like they wanted everyone reassessed.

  • MadMilan2019
    MadMilan2019 Online Community Member Posts: 190 Empowering
    edited June 2025

    We DO need to campaign to get abolition of ESA reversed, if at all possible, the more we make it hard for the govt to implement disability benefits reforms the better:

    May I suggest a template letter, and add your own individual comments for more impact:

    Dear MP, [ if you know not who your MP is go to ''findyourMP'' please.

    Good luck, and determination.

    Please can you tell my why ESA has been abolished.

    I have lost £

    a week about 121 quid.

    This has not been discussed in Parliament, or in the media.

    Why?

    Can you raise it as a Q at PMQs, and get back to us?

  • MadMilan2019
    MadMilan2019 Online Community Member Posts: 190 Empowering

    I agree with geckobat it is very confusing if LCRWA is retained or not under PIP UC reforms.

    Please go to

    www.cab.org.uk

    and Google ''Disability Rights UK''

    and report back to us all.

    You'd alleviate your own anxiety and confusion, and help others, if you did the above.

    We do need expert advice from the professionals.

  • Danny123
    Danny123 Online Community Member Posts: 223 Empowering

    I have no idea , I'm on cbesa and lcwra but no pip

    CBESA / new style ESA is said to be merging with jobseekers to make a new benefit called employment insurance , so I have absolutely no idea how that will affect my award or my NI credits

    Then when the WCA gets scrapped in 2028 I have no idea whether we will get assessed under current pip criteria or the new 4 point criteria.....

    Absolutely criminal what's happening to us , I guess will no more once the it gets passed .... Surely most will question this in the reading of the bill

  • geckobat
    geckobat Online Community Member Posts: 195 Empowering
    edited June 2025

    I'm on just LCWRA and my mind's been spinning since the start of this bill trying to understand what will happen. This side of it continues to be brushed over or mentioned only briefly. It's frustrating.

  • Danny123
    Danny123 Online Community Member Posts: 223 Empowering

    Absolutely , we will just have to stay alert and wait and see what gets passed and what doesn't .... It's such a mess at the minute there isn't much point trying to guess , were in the same boat so if I hear anything I'll let you know 👍

  • mawempathy
    mawempathy Online Community Member Posts: 150 Empowering

    I'm not referring to sites like this and B&W. I'm talking about communities on social networks, tiktok, etc. where there is absolutely no doubt people are being encouraged to game and cheat the system by people running accounts seeking followers and ad revenue.

  • mawempathy
    mawempathy Online Community Member Posts: 150 Empowering

    I never said the words "extremely large" or even "large". I'm saying these communities exist on popular social networks where clout chasers are encouraging people to quit their jobs and game the benefits system.

    The people running the accounts don't care about anyone but themselves. They want followers, views, ad revenues. The PIP system is now so clogged up with applications that people are waiting years to get decisions.

This discussion has been closed.