Job coaches for mentally ill in hospital settings - BBC

JonnycJonny
JonnycJonny Scope Member Posts: 253 Empowering

As previously posted here in an article from The Telegraph Liz Kendall has appeared on the BBC confirming the policy proposal.

Not posting this to scaremonger / sensationalise but to inform our community.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c98y09n8201o

«134

Comments

  • judie
    judie Community Member Posts: 339 Empowering

    Liz Kendall has demonstrated again and again that she has no detailed knowledge of disability and the relevant benefits for it. Ignorance of this level is dangerous

  • JonnycJonny
    JonnycJonny Scope Member Posts: 253 Empowering
    edited October 2024

    This is still a 'policy proposal' - to be detailed in the forthcoming White Paper.

    White Papers can be debated before a Bill is introduced, and may invite comments from the public. This allows for further discussion and consultation with affected groups, and for final changes to be made before the Bill is formally presented to Parliament.

    It is not yet policy.

    Best wishes

  • judie
    judie Community Member Posts: 339 Empowering

    It's a long way off - if it ever gets passed at all. Don't worry about it now, I am sure people with lived experience of MH and basically anyone with common sense will seek to inform her of what a terrible idea this is. As you say Catherine, imagine the carnage that would occur!

  • Meg24
    Meg24 Community Member Posts: 398 Trailblazing
    edited October 2024

    I'm so close to giving up. They have no idea what they're doing. If they think that people who are so seriously mentally ill they are hospitalised can be 'incentivised' to get a job, then they themselves are insane.

    What worries me now is what might be their presumption about people who have managed not to be sectioned. I've been having weekly therapy for over 20 years, it's kept me alive and out of hospital but I'm still hanging by a thread everyday.

    Deciding not to unalive yourself does not automatically cure severe depression or make it possible to successfully manage daily life, never mind be employed.

    I gave up having health screening tests years ago, I might have decided not to take negative steps as it stands, but I can't bring myself to take positive steps to prolong my life either.

    Right now I feel like I don't care anymore. I've spent years being active on forums, writing to my MP, filling in green papers etc etc. I can't be bothered anymore...

  • Sharebear
    Sharebear Community Member Posts: 97 Empowering
    edited October 2024

    I've been down a rabbit hole this morning, searching for part time job with no pressure from home.they just don't exist. I'm going to buy a laptop ready incase. I kind of feel like maybe this scare mongering is to see how many they can scare back to work ! I just don't know how I will do it. It's not fair that she's put pressure on to so many mh people. As for going into hospital when people at lowest there must be a law against this!!

    It's opening up doors for employers to also do this. My last two employers didn't believe mh was a disability and wouldn't make adjustments!!!

  • judie
    judie Community Member Posts: 339 Empowering

    I can't believe Kendall is speaking so lightly on this inhumane and discrimitary plan on the very day the Assisted Dying Bill is being discussed in the House of Commons which already has many disabled people feeling desperately afraid. It's disgusting treatment of the most vulnerable AGAIN

  • Numan
    Numan Community Member Posts: 39 Empowering

    And what if one of the contributing factors leading to being on a ward is the benefits system? How does that work? Feeling there is no escape route could be catostrophic.

  • Ross1975
    Ross1975 Posts: 1,128 Championing

    I don't know how much more of this I can take. ☹️

  • JasonRA
    JasonRA Community Member Posts: 315 Championing

    You cannot get someone who is seriously mentally ill into a job, if he or she has a breakdown in the workplace not only could it damage them it could damage the people around the person in question.

    I wonder if the thought has occurred to her that many seriously mentally ill people aren't 'safe' to do jobs?

    Also, what kind of prospective employer will, with open arms, positively embrace a candidate with serious mental health challenges, simply because that one has been "coached" and had a tailored CV provided?

  • durhamjaide2001
    durhamjaide2001 Scope Member Posts: 15,455 Championing

    I agree with the government out there that it could be helpful for some people. However this shouldn't be forced upon people. PEOPLE ARE ILL there so why put added stress if the person doesn't want a job

  • Ross1975
    Ross1975 Posts: 1,128 Championing

    Liz Kendall should be classed as not being fit for work herself as she's clearly a danger to some of the general public (us) due to her mental issues (cruelness, no compassion, no empathy, etc).

    Put her in the support group where she wont be a danger to anyone.

  • Ironside1990
    Ironside1990 Community Member Posts: 401 Pioneering

    I don't think this will get off the ground. The people who are in those units, are there for thier own and everyone else's safety and the staff are trained. I don't think they'll take kindly to a DWP goon trying to come in to hassle residents into taking up work.

    Liz Kendall is on another planet.

  • Numan
    Numan Community Member Posts: 39 Empowering

    There are many people in these units who are not only emotionally extremely unstable but have high degrees of paranoia towards anyone,be it staff,those in authority(doctors/government/DWP etc) or other patients. To be coerced to engage in this state could end very badly,for all and create new levels of trauma for patients.It would have to be ONLY on a non pressured ,voluntary basis, if at all.

  • Ironside1990
    Ironside1990 Community Member Posts: 401 Pioneering

    Feels like Labour are playing good cop bad cop. On the one hand, you've got Stephen Timms giving PIP claimants peace of mind by saying that vouchers won't be happening, then you've got Liz Kendall coming out with this ****, putting the fear of God in vulnerable people!

    We all know this will never happen, but she doesn't have an ounce of compassion in her!

    These are human beings!

  • Grissom123
    Grissom123 Community Member Posts: 116 Empowering

    I'm no expert or anything, but I'm pretty sure this ridiculous proposal could have some serious legal repercussions for the DWP.

    Anyone who has spent time in hospital knows how strict they are with regards to visitation. Most times it's only family members who are allowed, and this never happened with me but if it's someone you don't know, don't you have to give some kind of consent?

    I imagine very few hospitals would stand for some work coach just waltzing in and demanding access to patients. And surely this would be interfering in the doctor patient relationship, and also infringing on patient's privacy?

    I have no experience of being sectioned, but I imagine the visitation rules in those hospitals are even stricter? Surely they don't just let strangers in to see patients?

    This clearly hasn't been thought through properly and could potentially have disastrous consequences.

    Honestly if i God forbid made another suicide attempt and got visited by some idiot from a jobcentre to discuss writing my CV, I would tell them, and pardon my french, to go f**k themselves.

  • Sharebear
    Sharebear Community Member Posts: 97 Empowering
    edited October 2024

    This women needs a good talking too. She needs to know what it's like with any disability. I fought for 20 odd years with myself and managed to work with depression and anxiety. As I believed the routine would be better for me. After being told by one of my last employers I couldn't amend times I worked ( needed to go in on earlier less crowded bus) as she didn't see mh as a disability I founde it harder. Ended up on diazapam to get on bus and still struggled, i no longer use public transport and only leave my house if necessary. My body eventually just told me enough. Does this women look at how many have actually worked previously and then had to stop. Does she not realise we know how to write cvs? We definitely don't need some jumped up self important person telling us how to do this especially those who need hospital care. Maybe we should send her all the discussions that have been on scope alone where we are all worrying.

  • Sharebear
    Sharebear Community Member Posts: 97 Empowering

    She must be triggering so many people. It's so wrong

  • Sharebear
    Sharebear Community Member Posts: 97 Empowering

    @Nashota well done you I agree she is so clueless. I'm trying bit of zelda on switch to distract myself now

  • Meg24
    Meg24 Community Member Posts: 398 Trailblazing

    Has she said anything about their plans for people with MH issues who have never been sectioned? This whole "some people will lose their benefits" quote has me really worried.

  • Stellar
    Stellar Community Member Posts: 427 Pioneering

    oh look, the results of voting for Labour during the 2024 election are now becoming obvious to more people.

    i imagine a lot of people who voted Labour to "get the Tories out" now realise how much egg they have on their face.

    It was obvious the Labour party - now controlled by the hard right - were going to push stuff like this the moment they entered power. The evidence has been online for years. Most people chose not to listen.