Official thread: ‘Get Britain Working’ White Paper released Tuesday 26th November

17810121318

Comments

  • apple85
    apple85 Community Member Posts: 852 Championing
    edited December 2024

    sorry - would you be able to tell me what I said that wasn’t civil

    Little puzzled on what might of got flagged up as you know the last thing I’d want is to be purposely offensive, especially if there’s a better way

    Edit: really, that term? - I pride myself in being a polite person and I’m not into name calling for the sake of name calling, more for descriptive purposes if the shoe fits. (And honestly I didn’t want to discriminate against every right leaning as a few are more understanding once you explain the whole picture)

    I know 2 wrongs don’t make a right but I’ve also been cautioned for comparing certain politicians to certain animals (as other descriptives would be rude) and after all the names disabled people get thrown in their direction surely we should be allowed to vent on a disability forum without OTT censoring

    I do feel sometimes get my knuckles rapped by mods a little unfairly in comparison to other posts on scope forum I’ve read in the past that get no warnings and are left to slide (I don’t know if that’s because you know I’ll take the criticism on board and not everyone does?)

  • Albus_Alumni
    Albus_Alumni Scope alumni Posts: 11,373 Championing

    Not a problem @apple85 I'll private message you in a moment.

  • WhatThe
    WhatThe Community Member, Scope Member Posts: 5,709 Championing
    edited December 2024


    In my experience with the dwp it’s very black and white - either your too sick to work or do literally anything or it’s basically ‘you can do x so you are obviously healthy enough to full time work’ 

    Yes and this was the original 'binary' argument used by IDS for his scheme to migrate claimants from incapacity benefits to ESA starting 2008.

    We are absolutely on the same side (whatever we might think of Ed Davey😉) !

    I didn't make clear that he used the binary argument again in 2015 to reverse the two ESA components into a single one for LCWRA.

  • egister
    egister Posts: 1,102 Pioneering

    I believe that Kendall should personally register on this forum and answer questions personally. Of course she would never do that.

    😥

  • whistles
    whistles Community Member Posts: 2,051 Championing

    I could do voluntary.

  • Zipz
    Zipz Community Member Posts: 4,345 Championing
    edited December 2024
  • Ross1975
    Ross1975 Posts: 1,107 Championing
    edited December 2024

    If I worked I would not be able to cope with it, it'd destroy what little mental health I have and I'd end up suicidal.

    It really irritates me when politicians say working is good for your mental health. Yes it may be good for some people's mental health, but not for eveyones.

  • whistles
    whistles Community Member Posts: 2,051 Championing

    Don't read it would be my advice. I actually don't see these media posts or comments as I am not looking for it.

    I will look at a few places, but avoid what I call the gutter press.

  • whistles
    whistles Community Member Posts: 2,051 Championing

    Yes thank you. I never read social media comments, they are usually negative.

  • Tumilty
    Tumilty Community Member Posts: 497 Empowering

    My anxiety and depression is through the roof, as soon as I wake up it starts, I'm also helping my elderly parents who are struggling physically and they help me and I help them so it's really affecting my mental health trying to cope with it all. I'm on esa lcwra I think, panics me on how things will affect me.

  • Tumilty
    Tumilty Community Member Posts: 497 Empowering

    Yes Remina I agree, it makes me so angry listening to people in the media saying that a job would be good for people with anxiety and depression, just trivialising it as a temporary thing, bit of CBT then off to work you go.

    I'd love for some of these media people and politicians to only for an hour experience some of the stuff we go through day to day because as you say we habe have 'no proof' of how we are, maybe my scars are a little but I'd expect them to call it attention seeking or something.. The suicide rate is huge, can't they see that as proof of the problem, bit of CBT for someone suicidal ffs.

  • whistles
    whistles Community Member Posts: 2,051 Championing

    We won't know anything until Spring. So I am not giving this any more head space. I am not worrying for the next five months.

  • Ralph
    Ralph Community Member Posts: 135 Empowering

    Starmer’s Plan to Push Long Term Sick Into Work Risks ‘Devastating Deterioration’ of Conditions Costing Even More in the Long Run

    https://bylinetimes.com/2024/12/11/starmers-plan-to-push-long-term-sick-into-work-risks-devastating-deterioration-of-conditions-costing-even-more-in-the-long-run/

  • Adrian_Scope
    Adrian_Scope Posts: 14,427 Online Community Programme Lead

    Hi all,

    Just a quick note from me: I know it’s rough out there right now, especially with the attitudes towards disabled people being as they are.

    If you’re feeling anxious, depressed, or completely overwhelmed, please remember that there are places that can help. Mind has loads of resources for mental health, and you can call the Samaritans for free any time on 116 123—they’re always there to listen. If you’re stressed about money or benefits, Citizens Advice can be really useful.

    It’s okay to feel like this, but please make sure to look after yourselves, yeah? And don’t hesitate to reach out for support when you need it.

  • Tumilty
    Tumilty Community Member Posts: 497 Empowering

    Yes it is a very difficult time of year, all the xmas stuff can do one, since my dog died and both parents very unwell dealing with it on the on my own and the worry of what may happen in the spring.

    Surely the worst possible instances have to go through parliament and there will surely be mp's that aren't heartless towards us disabled people.. So annoys me that the amount of bonuses wealthy people get, foreign aid to countries that are wealthy anyway and or corrupt. Why not focus on people on jsa that have no intentions of doing anything. Are they going to drag people out of hospitals to work.

  • Andi66
    Andi66 Community Member Posts: 1,416 Championing

    Local elections are for local councillors , I think Mps are general elections, I wouldn't vote for my MP again,

  • Zipz
    Zipz Community Member Posts: 4,345 Championing

    @Catherine21 Local elections give an idea of how popular central government policy is. When a Council is won or lost tells an MP how he/she might fair in a General Election. I have a good Labour councillor but I'd be tempted to vote Green to give this government a shock.

  • worried33
    worried33 Community Member Posts: 1,054 Championing
    edited December 2024

    The press have now done it, seen two interviews asking ministers to name a company who is promoting work from home for people with health problems, they were pushed and refused to name a single company, also seen a similar interview for employers agreeing with the new employment laws, they just make stuff up.

    Ironically the 3 steps you put in was the Tories plan, descriptors for new claimants changed in 2025, then complete removal of LCWRA from everyone by 2029, to be replaced PIP health top up. (the latter would be equal cash support but not effect obligations for work related activity).

This discussion has been closed.