Green Paper Discussion (from 24th March, 2025)

@Catherine21

The government WANT the cuts going through for PIP in November 2026 but it doesn't necessarily mean it's going to happen.

This Green Paper at the moment is a consultation document with proposals to change the law on PIP and other cuts. As the situation stands, they want to quickly force other Labour MP's, under the three line whip, as it's called to approve these proposals to have it become a White Paper before the end of the current parliamentary session at the end of July.

There is a consultation period until the end of June, which, as you know, we can join in with, including here on Scope.

The MP's will then vote in July. As you are no doubt aware, they will probably be greatly swayed by the fact that they will be penalized by the removal of the whip if they don't toe the party line which means that even if they are against the cuts, the thought of being disciplined will more than likely, force their hand in voting the governments proposals through.

The good thing for us is that the government are trying to rush this through, to the white paper stage, in July without all the consultation they need. They are required to wait for the Office of Budget Responsibility, the OBR to give their own impact assessment, which won't be ready until October. Labour are ignoring this which means that their MP's won't have all the information required to vote on the proposals.

Don't panic though. This will actually work in our favour as Disability Activists /Groups will then be able to act after the White Paper, if it goes through in July, which is very likely.

To explain this properly, I will have to go back to the end of last year when activist Ellen Clifford, through the group Disabled People Against Cuts (I'm a member) won a high court case, having the previous government's disability green paper proposals declared unlawful. That was for a number of things particularly one, they had greatly overexaggerated the number of disabled people who could go back to work.

When the OBR, once they had done their impact assessment discovered that it would only be 3% of us, who would get jobs the Tories claims were completely discredited, so much so that it was one of the major reasons why their proposals were declared unlawful.

This government, as you can see are making mistakes, like the Tories. Being so keen to get this through without the OBR consultation then leaves them open to challenges from such as the DPAC in the high court. As you can see they ruined the chances of the last government with welfare cuts!

I was reading a post on here yesterday about under what circumstances will the high courts take action to stop the government from passing a law like this and to cut a long story short, Labour are breaking every single ones of those rules, believe it or not! These cuts weren't even in their mandate!

I'm sorry this has been so long but it is to show just how much they are leaving themselves completely open to challenge, which the DPAC are already preparing for.

This could also mean similar actions being bought by disability rights groups over such things as whether people such as ourselves who have already lost so much money and live on such a low income can, by law be forced into a strong possibility of destitution and homelessness through absolutely no fault of our own, to whether the fact that we have protected characteristics under equality law allows the government to make such devastating cuts to our income.

I not only wanted to explain how the system works but how, despite the horror and despair we all feel, there is actually very much more hope than you'd think. 👌🤗

I hope that has enlightened you about the situation. It's so complicated, I know! Do ask me to explain anything you don't understand, I find all this information takes a lot of getting into myself. It's even more difficult when you're not well too, isn't it. 🙄

I hope some others may read this post and feel better for doing so too. It just proves that in the most terrible situations there is always hope. 😀

Strange too, how vicious, vindictive people like the right wing section of this government will always try to cheat to try to get what they want through, tripping themselves up in the process because they are so arrogant and entitled, they think that they cannot possibly fail.

Especially as the Tories failed before them and their Green Paper was declared unlawful!! You could make it up could you!🤦

Please don't think that these laws are inevitable will you, there is everything to play for. Because they are the government it DOES NOT make them untouchable or infallible. 😊

Got a response from an MP who I contacted regarding the proposed cuts. The MP in question said she'll oppose these at every opportunity. I also got provided with links in the email of her doing so in the media.