Green Paper Related Discussions

18990929495189

Comments

  • Catherine21
    Catherine21 Online Community Member Posts: 9,796 Championing

    I believe great things are happening behind closed doors movement for red wall Corbyn McDonnell and all real labour mps there is still some who believe in its core values watch this space

  • Catherine21
    Catherine21 Online Community Member Posts: 9,796 Championing

    Apparently all mps are doing there own thing not even listening to starmer they can want what they want I believe more will vote against pip cuts and tories will vote against green lib dems they will do deliberately because they know how the public despises them would you want to be associated with a sinking ship thier evilness towards all UK citizens and even disabled minister walking over collapsed disabled woman shows mps charities any logical human being how we have been abused bullied victimised tormented threatened with our mere existence for years YEARS !! Labour came in and showed the world thiers is a wishlist of the global elites and now I finally understand the power of the people God have we shown them our next request if I could swear I would so I will say just leave us alone

    .back off !!!

  • secretsquirrel1
    secretsquirrel1 Online Community Member Posts: 2,052 Championing

    Catherine I saw this earlier and thought of you 😀. Everywhere it’s saying starmers days are numbered. I know people say the Labour Party don’t oust their PMs like the Tory’s do but I think these are different circumstances now .

  • secretsquirrel1
    secretsquirrel1 Online Community Member Posts: 2,052 Championing

    I sent the link to that article about Timms to Starmer , badenoch , Abraham’s and Jeremy. Think I’ll send it to Rayner tmrw. That should be all over the msm and he said be sacked , odious man

  • WhatThe
    WhatThe Online Community Member, Scope Member Posts: 5,535 Championing
    edited May 2025

    Jason They want to take the power GP's have of giving fit notes away also.

    (from A guide for General Practitioners and other doctors February 2010)

    "Why change? Improving your patients’ health through work. Evidence shows that work has therapeutic value and is generally good for physical and mental health.

    With the introduction of the new Statement the Forms Med 3 and Med 5 have been streamlined into one form. Also, because of the recent introduction of Employment and Support Allowance (ESA), you no longer have to fill in Form Med 4;"

    Med 4 medical evidence to support an incapacity benefits claim was abolished in 2010 and replaced with the 'fit note' for ESA.

    GPs' (and NHS Consultant doctors) exclusive authority to issue a Med 3 Statement to patients was abolished in 2016 and shared with any old 'health professional' you've never met. UC already does not have to accept a 'fit note' and is now telling GPs not to write one.

  • [Deleted User]
    [Deleted User] Posts: 1,170 Championing
    The user and all related content has been deleted.
  • [Deleted User]
    [Deleted User] Posts: 1,170 Championing
    The user and all related content has been deleted.
  • johnnyy85
    johnnyy85 Online Community Member Posts: 266 Empowering

    Hi Catherine

    Are you confident now that we will win this, with the numbers ?

  • johnnyy85
    johnnyy85 Online Community Member Posts: 266 Empowering
  • chiarieds
    chiarieds Online Community Member Posts: 17,439 Championing

    @WhatThe - whilst I can agree with one of your previous comments, but only in part (who has 'demanded' proof with links? I might have, I hoped, politely asked, that's all, & the better to understand - links help, & then a member will draw their own conclusion - so that comment of yours, as you're completely aware, is untrue).

    I do however agree that republishing propaganda may contribute to the 'mental torture' that some members might be putting themselves through. Everyone is trying to help tho, & will do so in their own way. Sharing what they've read in the media isn't trying to 'misinform' anyone else, & many members try to counter misinformation anyway.

    I've got very real concerns about misinformation spreading to the forum, & have done for years, but if you mistrust everyone & every source, as I hope to only use those I find are verifiable, then you & I are never going to agree on that one.

    I don't doubt you that previous reforms have gradually led to where we are today, but members are trying to concentrate on this Green Paper, as yes, there was comparitively 'much less communication by social media in 2012 & 2016'; some members may not even have been using the internet all those years ago.

    As to your 2nd comment, I think the idea was not to take a GP's 'power' away over 'fit' notes, rather acknowledging that this takes time out of a GP's day helping their patients with their medical problems, that it could be seen as a conflict of interest, & that other Healthcare Professionals might be in a better position to evaluate could a person return to work with sometimes reasonable adjustments, for example?

    And 'no' the 'authority' to give out a fit note was not 'shared with any old 'health professional' you've never met,' rather the opposite, as you needed to be their patient too. Please correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe that other Healthcare Professionals have only been able to write 'fit' notes since April 2024 (should they wish) as I remember mentioning this on the forum. But don't take my word for it: https://www.gov.uk/government/news/pm-to-overhaul-benefits-system-and-tackle-britains-sick-note-culture-in-welfare-reform-speech

    & a comment from May 2024: https://bjgplife.com/what-drives-the-sick-note-culture-in-the-uk/

    but yes, this is certainly thinking about getting people back into work, tho it's not relevant for PIP which is a disability benefit.

    I'm unsure how a WCA could be initiated without a fit note?

  • charlie72
    charlie72 Online Community Member Posts: 259 Pioneering

    Even if Reform were to vote in favour of cuts they would still be defeated.

    In favour of welfare changes:

    • Labour loyalists: 412 - 170 = 242
    • Reform UK: 5

    ➡ Total in favour: 242 + 5 = 247 MPs

    🧮 Final Tally:

    • For: 247
    • Against/Abstain: ~390

    🔴 Result: Welfare changes would still fail.

  • Ironside1990
    Ironside1990 Online Community Member Posts: 398 Pioneering

    i'd never thought we'd see the day that we'd get the Tories as allies.

  • secretsquirrel1
    secretsquirrel1 Online Community Member Posts: 2,052 Championing

    I read that but what I find confusing is in the article it says they’re voting against it as it’s not going far enough, yet I’m sure I heard the Tory’s said it was cruel . Mind you it’s the sun so maybe they added their little bit to it .

  • johnnyy85
    johnnyy85 Online Community Member Posts: 266 Empowering
  • johnnyy85
    johnnyy85 Online Community Member Posts: 266 Empowering
    edited May 2025

    What I would like to know is what can happen out of the two out comes ?
    It gets rejected ?

    What is the next step for the government will they try again?

    or it passes ?

    Would there be legal challenges ?

  • WhatThe
    WhatThe Online Community Member, Scope Member Posts: 5,535 Championing
    edited June 2025

    chiarieds, the PM in both your links is Rishi Sunak.

    "And 'no' the 'authority' to give out a fit note was not 'shared with any old 'health professional' you've never met"

    But it was!! The reforms I mentioned to Med 3 certification were enacted in 2016 and implemented from April 2017 (I think). DWP's subsequent plans will remove GPs entirely from the equation - the ones RS was talking about.

    "I don't doubt you that previous reforms have gradually led to where we are today, but members are trying to concentrate on this Green Paper,"

    It is gobbledegook without reference to existing rules and those rules should not have passed! There's no gradual. We've been conned but not by this PM.

  • WhatThe
    WhatThe Online Community Member, Scope Member Posts: 5,535 Championing
    edited June 2025

    The change is about efficiency and appropriateness, not about diminishing the GP’s role.

    That is exactly what was intended. What had served benefits claimants for 20 years was changed through the Welfare Reform and Work Act 2016. There was plenty of concern from GP's and the Local Government Association (LGA) at the time.

    There is zero appropriateness at DWP where claimants' health is concerned.

  • [Deleted User]
    [Deleted User] Posts: 1,170 Championing
    The user and all related content has been deleted.
  • [Deleted User]
    [Deleted User] Posts: 1,170 Championing
    edited June 2025
    The user and all related content has been deleted.
This discussion has been closed.