Scope's reply to the governments planned concessions to the green paper.

1111214161752

Comments

  • mawempathy
    mawempathy Online Community Member Posts: 150 Empowering

    Do you honestly believe the additional 365,000 PIP claimants we're forecast to add in 2025 are largely a result of long covid? FYI, I have a relative with long covid who used to be very active… and now she struggles to even play with her kids. She's had heart monitors strapped on and all sorts. So I do understand how debilitating it can be.

  • mawempathy
    mawempathy Online Community Member Posts: 150 Empowering

    People who are genuinely missing out on what they're entitled to is not an excuse for others to just help themselves because Dave made a nice tiktok explaining how to do it. Many probably choose not to claim it, because they don't need it.

  • mawempathy
    mawempathy Online Community Member Posts: 150 Empowering

    If we think it's better to have thousands of people claiming money they are not entitled to, then we shouldn't mind if we have to share our financial support (by way of cuts) with them.

  • mawempathy
    mawempathy Online Community Member Posts: 150 Empowering

    Most of the figures are produced independently of the government. But I respect we're never going to agree on this, so I wish you all the best too mate.

  • Stellar
    Stellar Online Community Member Posts: 409 Pioneering

    Thank you for this. One reason why the British left in general - not just disability rights - continue to fail at basic politics is because so many of them behave like Trevor. Any advocate who's work isn't rooted in humanity, compassion, critical thinking, and a basic knowledge of the facts will harm others, even when they don't realise or intend to.

    Also agree with this. So sorry to hear about your sister.

  • Stellar
    Stellar Online Community Member Posts: 409 Pioneering

    AI will be a disaster for disabled people both in and out of work. Employers can - and will - use AI to replace a lot of jobs that disabled people can do (although it won't specifically target them).

    The best way for anyone to survive in an AI-dominated world is to improve their soft skills and personal brand. Both these things are harder for disabled people, thanks to unconscious bias and for some, their disabilities themselves.

    AI also reflects these systemic bigotries, just as it does with race. Disabled people seeking benefits - regardles of whether they work or not - will get unfairly declined.

  • Catherine21
    Catherine21 Online Community Member Posts: 9,796 Championing
    Screenshot_20250629_134639_Facebook.jpg

    Love This

  • Stellar
    Stellar Online Community Member Posts: 409 Pioneering

    Nope. If people are claiming money they aren't entitled to, that in itself is a sign of a broken society. It dosen't pay to work in the UK due to this country's regressive taxation system, so of course people will find a way to survive. this usually dosen't involve benefits though, rather legally dodging taxes. this is why many work cash in hand.

    Those who can afford to share their financial support are overwhelmingly rich. their income must be cut via taxation and repossessing some of their assets. not disabled people or fraudsters

  • alexroda
    alexroda Online Community Member Posts: 377 Trailblazing

    Let’s take for instance this grotesque new Employment Insurance the government want to bring in.

    They are offering a staggering amount of little more than £400 for those who have been fired from a job or have become too ill to work. 

    I think it’s unclear for how long this pittance will be paid. I seem to remember reading that they were suggesting 6 months.


    In other European countries is about £1200 a month and lasts for TWO years. After those two years if you are still too ill to work you can get further help, which could amount to thousands of pounds a month, plus council housing etc.

  • Zipz
    Zipz Online Community Member Posts: 4,351 Championing

    How do you work that out? A PIP claimant in a good job could easily have savings of £16K plus. Therefore, no UC.

  • Zipz
    Zipz Online Community Member Posts: 4,351 Championing

    @Catherine21 No. The Speaker doesn't have to accept ammendments tabled.

  • [Deleted User]
    [Deleted User] Posts: 1,170 Championing
    edited June 2025
    The user and all related content has been deleted.
  • Zipz
    Zipz Online Community Member Posts: 4,351 Championing

    @YogiBear @luvpink and I will be battered by the Employment Insurance Benefit. It is preposterous to lump together a healthy JSA claimant with a lifelong disabled ESA claimant.

  • Karl99
    Karl99 Online Community Member Posts: 15 Contributor

    This is the real horror of it, combining normal Jobseekers with disabled people in the ESA Support group who have been medically assessed in the same way as those on PIP, just as if they are equal. This is will lead to poverty and suicide. It’s pure evil.

  • Catherine21
    Catherine21 Online Community Member Posts: 9,796 Championing

    That side yes I can see but if the DWP played fair on genuine claimants with evidence loads of evidence that would be very confident thier doing the right thing but nah they target a majority of claimants who are obviously entitled and still make them suffer and jump through hoops

  • Catherine21
    Catherine21 Online Community Member Posts: 9,796 Championing

    They made everything a mess absolute mess so was that a consultation they arranged in your area ?

  • Karl99
    Karl99 Online Community Member Posts: 15 Contributor

    I’ve written to my MP Louise Elizabeth Jones, twice now, and her replies are that she’s towing the Starmer line. Enjoy being an MP while it lasts dear.

  • Danny123
    Danny123 Online Community Member Posts: 223 Empowering

    There is no way there is that many people a day getting awarded pip , that is that silly rehtoric that they roll out when they get stuck trying to defend themselves , absolute rubbish

  • Stellar
    Stellar Online Community Member Posts: 409 Pioneering

    Other groups already have. Trans people have effectively lost legal rights and safe access to services, and asylum seekers are also facing similar barriers.

    the other things you've outlined are why i, as a disabled person who's currently able to look towards working, seeka to move abroad long term. i suspect a lot of younger brits - even ableds - will do the same.

This discussion has been closed.