Official thread: ‘Get Britain Working’ White Paper released Tuesday 26th November

11213151718

Comments

  • chiarieds
    chiarieds Online Community Member Posts: 16,673 Championing
    edited December 15

    Following on from what @Amaya_Ringo has just said, I'd also wondered how many disabled people do work, & how many like myself worked until they had to retire early due to their disability/were now retired after working their whole life. This had followed on from @MW123 previously asking how many disabled people like themselves are actually working, but there was no response from Scope.

    A while back Scope said that there were 1 million disabled people who would like to work so I wondered if that was an up to date figure.

    I listened to the Work & Pensions Committee meeting held last month. In that it was said that the Office for National Statistics had just said that there were 2.8 million people out of work with a long term health condition.

    Liz Kendall then said that there are 4 million disabled people working with a health limiting condition according to official reports, & that 2+ million disabled people hope to work if appropriate work could be found with reasonable adjustments.

    So, unfortunately Scope's data about disabled people who would like to work is only half of the real figure, & they really should update their 'facts,' & it shows that their are more disabled people working than not. Scope should be emphasizing this point in any of their discussions with the govt, as I think Amaya would agree.

    Definitely the media's narrative is wrongly skewed.

  • Kaliwax
    Kaliwax Online Community Member Posts: 85 Empowering
    edited December 15

    I just self harmed myself because of some of the comments the people have been making about the disabled online.

    Let's withdraw benefits was some of the comments people was making, others was saying, ration for them, and make everything on benefits vouchers, some really cruel suggestions. It makes me angry these comments.

    I just wanted to respond to every one of them, but resisted my temptation to do so. People think being disabled and on benefits is fun it isn't. I'm in constant pain all day mentally and I can never ever feel comfortable or happy.

  • Andi66
    Andi66 Online Community Member Posts: 502 Pioneering

    Please don't read or listen to these comments, they are ignorant. They have no understanding of what it's like to be disabled. The media fuels this unfortunately. Take time for yourself and focus on you. Take care

  • MW123
    MW123 Scope Member Posts: 861 Championing

    You're right, these statistics should be central to discussions with the government and the media. James Taylor’s response to Isabel Oakeshott’s comments in November missed an important opportunity to address the employment status of disabled people. While he acknowledged the barriers they face, he overlooked the fact that many disabled individuals are actively employed.

    Chiarieds as you pointed out, some disabled people have had to retire early or after a lifetime of work, while others contribute through volunteering. Their efforts deserve recognition. Had Taylor highlighted that PIP helps cover the extra costs of living with a disability, regardless of employment status, his statement would have been more effective.

    A more impactful response would have included data on the employment rates of PIP recipients, showcasing their resilience and contributions. By focusing on both progress and challenges, Scope can advocate for policies that support the employment aspirations of disabled people and ensure proper support for those unable to work. This approach would foster a more inclusive job market and challenge harmful stereotypes about disability.

    While Taylor's statement effectively defends benefits and challenges damaging language, it misses an opportunity to highlight the contributions of disabled individuals who are working or volunteering. Recognising these contributions would have strengthened his message, demonstrating that, when given the opportunity, disabled people are valuable members of the workforce.

  • Catherine21
    Catherine21 Posts: 2,795 Championing

    I understand it's cruel mental torture these people not relize the harm thied words cause and some are just cruel the funny thing is people don't have the mind to think this could happen to them at any don't listen to them we can all support each other x

  • worried33
    worried33 Online Community Member Posts: 599 Pioneering
    edited December 16

    Its all very odd, none of these figures have credibility, and there is a game of chinese whispers between Scope and the DWP currently.

    By the time anything is public the "decision has been made, nothing left to consult, discuss".

  • Ironside1990
    Ironside1990 Online Community Member Posts: 218 Empowering

    Just read on benefitsandwork.co.uk that we won't hear a verdict on the DWP and Ellen Clifford court case until the new year.

  • michael57
    michael57 Online Community Member Posts: 886 Trailblazing

  • Amaya_Ringo
    Amaya_Ringo Online Community Member Posts: 231 Empowering

    Chiarieds, that's it exactly.

    I lost my job during the last government 'push to get disabled into work' under Cameron and I feel like the same is likely again this time because I work for local government and they're already talking about cuts. The fact that disabled people disproportionately work in local government or public sector because accessibility is better understood seems to have been overlooked.

    The lack of understanding in government even about what benefit does what is also staggering. The fact some of the media are talking about PIP then describing ESA shows a complete lack of research going into any of these reports as well.

    Kaliwax, please take care of yourself. The people commenting online are doing so out of spite - not knowledge. Unfortunately some people glean enjoyment from hurting others. Those people are the pitiful ones, though. You are a warrior, stay strong.

  • chiarieds
    chiarieds Online Community Member Posts: 16,673 Championing

    @worried33 - I think there's credibility in the figures provided by the Office for National Statistics. The fact that more disabled people work rather than not 'should' counter the unfortunate negative narrative that the media is displaying.

    As mentioned by both @Amaya_Ringo & @MW123 both of whom work, highlighting this 'should' perhaps in part negate the media's skewed response, whilst understanding that some people simply cannot work & should continue to have the utmost support.

    Amaya also highlights that for some disabled people in work there's no job security, which surely also needs to be addressed?

    I hope Scope take some of this onboard & we can all continue to be on the same page. I just wish people could avoid social media & it's too harmful narrative. Every disabled person matters; everyone here matters, whether able to work or not.

  • Kaliwax
    Kaliwax Online Community Member Posts: 85 Empowering

    Thanks,

    One of the barriers people seem to see this isn't just for disabled people, but in general is buses. Arriva down my way are cutting everything from next year, my last bus is 5pm, compared to 4 years ago where we had 4 buses an hour each way. a sunday service and an evening service. People will struggle to get to work with a service like that

  • Andi66
    Andi66 Online Community Member Posts: 502 Pioneering
  • worried33
    worried33 Online Community Member Posts: 599 Pioneering
    edited December 17

    I have seen one figure from the ONS, one that predicts only a tiny fraction of those planning to be moved to LCW will find work.

    The page I am on, I am all for legitimate support schemes to help people back to work, I think there is sick and disabled people who want to work (I am one of them), but I think there is also way too many assumptions that get made about what people are capable of doing, and I am firmly against moving people to LCW just on a bet it will work out for them. I am firmly against mandated activity, firmly against sanctions, and firmly against removing financial support, The DWP should be capable of providing voluntarily support to people in LCWRA, they shoudnt need to use a threat regime to provide support or need to remove financial support to provide back to work support either.

    The difference between me and Kendall, is Kendall thinks its a mission to get people working, that is the end goal, I dont have this obsession the whole country should be working, for me its providing the safety net for those that need it, working on giving them treatment, a diagnosis, a support circle, whilst carefully helping those who want to attempt to get back into work, making sure they not penalised for doing so either (current regime will penalise it). The DWP can do so much more than just give out financial support.

    The assessment process also has very little to do with this other that it can penalise attempts to go back into work, the DWP dont need a new process to provide support to people. They need a new process to save 3 billion a year, and push people into LCW or FFW. If they were serious about genuinely helping people, there would be no talk of assessment changes.

    I go on statements from ministers, and parliament not the news media speculation.

    Going back to scope.

    I would like to see them publish minutes or a summary of any dialogue from the DWP.
    Surveys of scope members about their interactions with the DWP, so they understand what sick and disabled people are experiencing and need from the DWP,
    Encourage the DWP (ideally the ministers, but someone who has influence on policy within DWP would be ok also) to speak to claimants directly for their feedback, on an individual level not consultations with fixed questions.
    Ask the ministers to setup an independent regulator for the DWP so something is keeping them in check.

  • Andi66
    Andi66 Online Community Member Posts: 502 Pioneering

    This is from benefits and work, about Pip, dwp complete disarray

    https://www.benefitsandwork.co.uk/news/dwp-meltdown-spreads-to-pip-mrs

  • Nightcity
    Nightcity Online Community Member, Scope Member Posts: 2,670 Championing

    Then they REALLY need to pause this migration before it becomes a major problem all round.

  • Amaya_Ringo
    Amaya_Ringo Online Community Member Posts: 231 Empowering

    Kaliwax, you really don't want to get me started complaining about buses! LOL :) We had a great bus years ago but for political reasons it was taken off our neighbourhood and rooted into one more sympathetic to our council at the time. Since then we've had so much trouble with buses. Our current service is running so infrequently that there is one bus I can get to work, and generally am reliant on the last bus to get back. There's one bus all morning for people with passes to get to the local market town.

    When I was in London studying, I had transport and freedom for the first time since I was teenager. But here I have none of that. I am not comfortable in taxis so I basically have a curfew. And since I have to get the last bus home, I can't do anything on work days either. My navigation is too poor, especially in the dark, for me to be able to vary my means of transport much.

    And I have lost so many better job opportunities because I have no transport. This seems to be an area the government white paper isn't even touching on. How do we disabled, non-driving folk get to our places of work? I already have to leave over an hour earlier than I should have to because there is no bus in that direction for 2 and a half hours after mine.

    And this last couple of weeks alone I've waited over an hour in cumulative minutes for it when it's been late.

  • Andi66
    Andi66 Online Community Member Posts: 502 Pioneering

    Mine the same where I live , that's what I voted our usless uncaring MP for as he was going to sort the buses out. He hasn't. Made out he was for the people ,he's not.

  • stay_positive
    stay_positive Online Community Member Posts: 375 Empowering

    You need to think about these people , they are trolls and enjoy winding people up , most of them are probably on benefits too . They are not worth hurting yourself , and I know how that is as I used to self harm . The best way to deal with them is to not respond which you did and that would hurt them more because they never got the reaction they craved .

  • Catherine21
    Catherine21 Posts: 2,795 Championing

    Someone said the reason for cancelling local elections as in couple of years mayor's will run areas ? Does that make sense

  • Andi66
    Andi66 Online Community Member Posts: 502 Pioneering

    They are panicking because they now reform will do good in local elections and take their seats.