Official thread: ‘Get Britain Working’ White Paper released Tuesday 26th November

191012141518

Comments

  • Catherine21
    Catherine21 Posts: 2,795 Championing

    Everything is designed to keep us down they know the answers for 22 black fiction hole tax the highest earners 2 percent and loads of other stuff they could do to make our country and life's good healthy happy this is exactly where they want everyone to be sad but I believe true

  • Albus_Scope
    Albus_Scope Posts: 8,327 Scope Online Community Coordinator

    I think that's a very negative way of looking at things @Catherine21 I don't think everything is designed to keep us down at all and the government know making us unhappy is ultimately a bad decision. 😆

    I'd still love to know exactly where you're reading these things, as I'd like to have a look myself. Just to see if they're coming from reputable sources. 😊

  • whistles
    whistles Online Community Member Posts: 1,945 Championing

    I actually rarely read things as news is just designed to create panic, drama and doesn't often publish facts.

    There isn't anything wrong with encouraging people back into work. Those that CAN work. We have people trapped on lcwra, by trapped I mean left to rot, no support, no encouragement. It doesn't change until you are assessed. We are dumping thousands of working age people on the scrap heap.

    I have a lifelong condition(s) , but before Covid and PIP I was doing voluntary work.

  • Andi66
    Andi66 Online Community Member Posts: 502 Pioneering

    I would like to try volunteering, as working would be impossible with my health problems. I'm hoping the government would encourage it for those unable to work. As at least it contributed. And sitting at home rotting not good.

  • apple85
    apple85 Online Community Member Posts: 733 Championing

    I wouldn’t use the word ‘trapped’

    However in many cases that you try and take a positive step towards getting off the system you need to think twice as it could trigger reassessment or overwise

    In my experience with the dwp it’s very black and white - either your too sick to work or do literally anything or it’s basically ‘you can do x so you are obviously healthy enough to full time work’ - there’s not a middle ground or steps towards a to z (my old work coach who seemed to like me as I was one of the few claimants that was polite to her warned me off the record not to make any major step towards work unless I was 100% ready for the jobcentre to start pushing for any old job interviews)

    so I wouldn’t used the word trapped - but being a disabled claimant trying to move off system into suitable & safe work is like hiking up mount Fiji and the dwp fill your rucksack with ridiculously heavy dumbbell weights………….

    And these extra barriers blocking the possibility of success does disillusion over time - every time you try and fail or get blocked your MH and self worth takes a hit and it gets harder and harder to muster the energy to try again (and it’s a bad attitude to have but you do end up thinking why bother if everything is stacked up towards failure or your life/health decreasing substantially regardless)

    On this thread I’ve suggested that prehaps long term we are best trying to jump through labours hope to stop an even worse case scenario for disabled being trusted on in 4 years (apparently the guardian was thinking along the same lines)

    https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2024/dec/06/labour-government-keir-starmer-nigel-farage

    however the dwp do need to do their part in ripping down multiple ‘barriers’, totally change the culture & thought process of job centres and dwp staff, provide more forms of actual help and provide more definitions to the word ‘success’ (note to Kendall, timms and McGovern - paid employment is not the only useful contribution that disabled ppl can make to society and saying it to media every few days do not make it so nor does it endear you to the disabled community)

  • apple85
    apple85 Online Community Member Posts: 733 Championing

    I’m not sure Kendall personally reads her own email and I’m not sure their egos would allow them to consider an idea that they didn’t come up with.

    I think Kendall said that she wanted to collaborate with the disabled community in terms of future reform - if there is another dwp public consultation it’s more like the one streeting launched for the nhs a couple of weeks back where all suggestions & ideas can be submitted no matter how bonkers (instead of begging the dwp to use their common sense as to why pip and vouchers don’t mix)

    @Andi66 theres a couple of things I can’t post in official term on this thread - would it be okay to PM you some point over the coming week?

  • WhatThe
    WhatThe Online Community Member, Scope Member Posts: 2,677 Championing
    edited December 7

    In my experience with the dwp it’s very black and white - either your too sick to work or do literally anything or it’s basically ‘you can do x so you are obviously healthy enough to full time work’ 

    Yes and this was the original 'binary' argument used by IDS for his scheme to migrate claimants from incapacity benefits to ESA starting 2008.

  • WhatThe
    WhatThe Online Community Member, Scope Member Posts: 2,677 Championing

    Kendall's contribution to Labour's 2015 Disability Manifesto should be revisited..

  • Catherine21
    Catherine21 Posts: 2,795 Championing

    So depressed with it all my dad ill he's given up he's tired he said he knows he won't be here long I have no siblings this will break me

  • Catherine21
    Catherine21 Posts: 2,795 Championing

    No just from observations really

  • apple85
    apple85 Online Community Member Posts: 733 Championing
    edited December 7

    I think there are so many articles being written by the far right media and disablity activists that they all merge into one another and it’s very easy for mind to get warped by it all especially when you have trouble turning off and ignoring things.

    On your comment that this labour government know making the disabled community is a bad decision - I’m not so sure

    There are many of the public that see disabled as dead weight that don’t contribute anything and that welfare should be cut and disabled forced to work (though some of the same ppl contradict themselves by saying they don’t want to work in the some place as a disabled person) - basically red meat politics

    I’m not sure there’s a way for labour to make both groups happy so may pick to (try and) make the group most likely to help them next GE in terms of votes ‘happy’

    I’m not sure either the [removed by moderator - uncivil] right leaning public (those individuals believing the right wing press narrative on welfare and the disabled) or disabled community will ever be ‘happy’ with labours choices and starmer may have already lost voters from both groups - however financially the ‘easy’ option in terms of the gov saying money is to cut welfare and tighten criteria for awards (it shouldn’t be as it should weigh on the conscience - not sure many politicians have sleepless nights over disabled they’ve forced into poverty - esp as starmer only seems to value ‘working people’)


    I really hope I’m wrong - but every couple of days we are getting new, harmful sound bites from dwp ministers such as Kendall, timms and mcgovern - I’m not sure what are the odds that none of them realise the damage and hurt they are causing with their constant stream of verbal ‘grenades’ and the amount of goodwill ‘currency’ they are wasting and are just obvious to it all (rather than being intended ‘targeting’)

  • Albus_Scope
    Albus_Scope Posts: 8,327 Scope Online Community Coordinator

    Let's please be careful with comments like the one I've had to edit please @apple85 remember the house rules, let's keep it civil.

  • Catherine21
    Catherine21 Posts: 2,795 Championing

    Also the silence is deafening I know labour is the better choice than reform and tories I know that I just thought things would have been a little bit easier under them and for me personally it feels suffocating not knowing which way to turn its the unknown and the uncertainty and I feel they been spoon feeding us bit by bit which is in my eyes extremely cruel

  • Albus_Scope
    Albus_Scope Posts: 8,327 Scope Online Community Coordinator

    Sorry to hear that @Catherine21 we're all here if you need us. ❤️

  • apple85
    apple85 Online Community Member Posts: 733 Championing

    I should edit that to “in my experience over the past 6-7 years” - during the Tory/lib dem coalition and before 10 years ago there was actually some flexibility in the dwp/jobcentre

    There was disability specifically trained jobcentre advisers (they all got retrained as uc work coaches 4-6 years back and don’t cater to specific claimant needs) and they were more then happy (encouraged & didn’t threaten reassessment or sanctions if you wants to try and earn a little pocket money - there’s no way in hell you could get away with that in 2024)

    Ironically it may be best for the jobcentres to go backwards then to ‘evolve’ (god knows what it will turn into) and over a decade ago there were a few good ideas which should of never been ditched


    @WhatThe - I can’t tell if you are agreeing or disagreeing with me - it’s cool either way as everyone’s entitled to their own opinion

  • apple85
    apple85 Online Community Member Posts: 733 Championing
    edited December 7

    sorry - would you be able to tell me what I said that wasn’t civil

    Little puzzled on what might of got flagged up as you know the last thing I’d want is to be purposely offensive, especially if there’s a better way

    Edit: really, that term? - I pride myself in being a polite person and I’m not into name calling for the sake of name calling, more for descriptive purposes if the shoe fits. (And honestly I didn’t want to discriminate against every right leaning as a few are more understanding once you explain the whole picture)

    I know 2 wrongs don’t make a right but I’ve also been cautioned for comparing certain politicians to certain animals (as other descriptives would be rude) and after all the names disabled people get thrown in their direction surely we should be allowed to vent on a disability forum without OTT censoring

    I do feel sometimes get my knuckles rapped by mods a little unfairly in comparison to other posts on scope forum I’ve read in the past that get no warnings and are left to slide (I don’t know if that’s because you know I’ll take the criticism on board and not everyone does?)

  • Albus_Scope
    Albus_Scope Posts: 8,327 Scope Online Community Coordinator

    Not a problem @apple85 I'll private message you in a moment.

  • Catherine21
    Catherine21 Posts: 2,795 Championing

    I'm so heartbroken seeing him scared confused he used to be such a character we had funny relationship over years but very close now just me and him

  • WhatThe
    WhatThe Online Community Member, Scope Member Posts: 2,677 Championing
    edited December 7


    In my experience with the dwp it’s very black and white - either your too sick to work or do literally anything or it’s basically ‘you can do x so you are obviously healthy enough to full time work’ 

    Yes and this was the original 'binary' argument used by IDS for his scheme to migrate claimants from incapacity benefits to ESA starting 2008.

    We are absolutely on the same side (whatever we might think of Ed Davey😉) !

    I didn't make clear that he used the binary argument again in 2015 to reverse the two ESA components into a single one for LCWRA.